Altered unison position

Dorico gives me:

I want:

Any way to get that without faking it?

I think the answer is “no”.
The closest I could find (in Engrave mode) was to select the A# on the split stem and alter the value of Properties > Note Spacing > Split stem X offset. [Keep scrolling to the right until you find it.]

While it would accept very large values (100+) and move the notehead to the right accordingly, the lowest negative value (to move the notehead to the left) which it would act on was -1.15, despite greater negative values being entered. This resulted in the sharp sign partly covering the notehead of the A natural.

Also, the attachment point of the split stem to the main stem could not be altered.

So, it looks like it will have to be faked.

One other Property which might potentially be useful (but not in this situation, unfortunately) is that when the notehead on the split stem is selected, Split stem notehead att: becomes available in the Notes and Rests section.

This allows the user to change the position at which the split stem attaches to the notehead.

I also had a look in Notation Options > Altered Unisons, but there does not appear to be anything which might help in your particular situation.

Here you go.

It took me a couple of minutes, but it is possible to fake it.

I have attached the Dorico file in case you wish to use it, study it, etc.

Split stem.dorico (1.5 MB)

Thanks! @StevenJones01 Your files shows an excellent way to fake it, and I will do that. I had tried some of the possibilities that you mentioned in your first post, but had even less success than you did.

After posting the file I did a bit more “fiddling” with it. It is possible to copy and paste the notation (if you need it somewhere else as well), but the attachment points of the line (substituting for the split stem) will probably need to be adjusted in Engrave mode.

Yes, I found that copying and pasting worked well except for the fake stems.

Hi @John_Ruggero, beside the suggestion by @StevenJones01, I found another method, which doesn’t require a line (that will change its position if the layout changes…)

The method is based on two principles:

  • To force a left split stem you need multiple altered unison notes (then hide what you don’t need, probably the right one). You need to activate this Notation Option, though:

  • Dorico does split stems so that the split notes are written from lower to higher pitch (from left to right). To force the sequence of accidentals, you can use bb or x accidentals for the extra (hidden) unison note


Result:

Dorico file example:
force left Split stem-alternative method.dorico (1.4 MB)

The examples (you find them in flow 1):

Here a visual guide for your needs (as in flow 2):


(For reference see also this post:)

That is an extremely clever solution @Christian_R but I ran into a problem at 2 in your example. How did you move the lower accidental away from the note?

I get this without adjustment:

and when I adjust the lower sharp it moves the A natural far from the A#.

What am I doing wrong?

It’s the step 4 of @Christian_R’s solution: select the A natural and decrease the Split Stem X offset (under the Note Spacing section of the properties).

Thanks @charles_piano That did it.

@StevenJones01 Thank you again for your help. @Christian_R’s solution would seem to be the definitive one, and I will therefore check his solution box for future reference.

Here is the passage using Christian_R’s solution:

:

I would likely use enharmonic equivalents to avoid the split-stemming whenever I could; but I realize split-stems are there for a reason, and knowing how to arrange them as desired is worthwhile..

In the above example from John, the a’’ stays through all those bars like a high pedal note, while the notes around it change. Using enharmonic alternatives would obscure the melody and make it more difficult to read.

I’m probably stating the obvious… but the altered A# in @Christian_R ‘s solution — since it is moved ‘up’ to the enharmonic B — shouldn’t it be B-flat? (Or am I missing something?)
I do prefer the enharmonic spelling over the split stems, BTW!
— Jim
Edit: I didn’t see the later posts by @Derrek & @k_b / @John_Ruggero — good points!

It’s from Ravel’s piano solo arrangement of La Valse and uses his spelling. The A natural is part of the prevailing harmony, the A# is the chromatic lower neighboring tone to the B in the melody.