In a live stream, I heard Thomas Fiedler say that you should use 9.1.6 if possible as everything was moving towards that (though I think he was speaking from a musical vantage point and this is a post production discussion). Anyone doing this?
Unfortunately the Atmos Renderer is limited to 7.1.4.
Fredo
Did you mean 12 or 14?
Version 14 now supports 9.1.6, along with 5.1.4 downmix/fold-down and trim functionality.
Additionally, internal adjustments have been made for perfect calibration with the external Dolby renderer, though these changes are not explicitly detailed.
The Nuendo internal renderer.
Fredo
You should absolutely be worried about the fold down. 5.1 is where the majority of “immersive” listeners will be living.
I’d argue it’s headphones…but I get where you are coming from when it applies to a home consumer’s surround setup or soundbar. To me it depends on the customers you are preparing your product for in the end. (obviously the majority of immersive audiobook listeners will be in headphones for example, TV Shows / Movies would be home theater). Are you super focused on your stereo re-renders or mixes for people that do not have surround systems? Super tough to prepare for so many different setups without supplying multiple different mixes.
But… I think the question is more so related to the limitations of the renderer bed and folding down into said bed, and preferences in post…But I’m just a spectator here in the end, and don’t want to be a thread killer, so i’ll bow out from here
![]()
No worries - I believe your points are legit and worthy of inclusion. Fredo asked if getting all involved with 7.1.4 verbs and the like are worth the effort. You can’t discuss this topic without considering the end destination.
I am personally finding the 7.1.2 bed a giant pain, especially wih regard to Immersive Reverb Plugs! While, I expected an easier transition from regular surround to ATMOS because it covered 90% of the regular surround territory and the fact that I was mixing music only, I thought that just adding a pair of Top Rear Only monitors would allow me to call it a day.
But the reality is that a 7.1.4 Object Bed is much more flexible, requires a lot less routing sub matrices and actually sounds better. As such, I was getting into the habit of just leaving the 7.1.2 bed empty and working with the remaining 118 objects. Then, I find out the end playback is actually 5.1+Quad from most mastering houses (at least that’s how it’s reading on the Bluray/DVD/SACD credits).
Now you’re saying that the streaming services are actually giving preferential treatment to the 7.1.2 bed?! THAT is very discouraging news. What’s the logic behind that? Theater deliverables are different frome Home Theater deliverables and now both are different from Streaming deliverables and NONE of them remain consistent from creation to end use! I thought the entire point of this platform was to be able to MAKE ONE FILE and all the playback formats would decode it properly (SAME as the studio mix), from full range to binaual fold down for the consumer.
This is like playing “Whack A Mole!”
I observe technology for fun, There’s just a limited amount of human input required for ai implementation, the dolby designed suits are prepared that way. Music with 6 channel bed layout is the top priority. The entire reselling of 5.1 with atmos is also fishy, all explanations regarding the delivery limitations are lies.