Artificial harmonics - possible to "disconnect" the stem?

Here are two notations of the same artificial harmonic:

The first is the standard Dorico method using the lower panel to turn a note into an artificial harmonic.

My problem is that the stem connecting both the bottom note and the ‘touch’ note above makes it easily misread it as a double stop of two normals notes.

The second notation is possible with MANY steps - entering the notes in different voices, hiding rests, removing the stem on the top note - possible but way too cumbersome. (This is how I did harmonics in Finale for a few decades.)

Is it possible to NOT have the stem connect the two noteheads? I’m guessing this is not standard notation but it always seemed clearer to me.

IMO no string player would ever misread the standard notation, but might be confused by your second.

9 Likes

@Janus is correct, at least for this string player. Without the connecting stem, I would be inclined to think the diamond was a typo, intended to be the circle that (in this case) indicates the open A string.

1 Like

In my experience as a string player, the connected stem is the normal notation for artificial harmonics. I can assure you we recognise a diamond notehead. And yes, it is kind of a double stop anyway, but on the same string. We know.

4 Likes