Thank you Novikthewise and Fabio for your observation.
Based on your experiences I’ve extended these tests to audio files as well.
I’m sorry I couldn’t reply sooner, but it took 13 hours to test and re-test and cross reference with another DAW that I only use for this kind of testing purposes.
I’ve made a Q&A form, for easier understanding.
Q1: Does the Asio Guard when it is Activated changes the sound quality with audio files only?
-Yes.
When global Asio Guard Activated and just playing back simple audio tracks, a composition(*) in Cubase with no modifications to them in any way, then changing the buffer size of the audio interface example from 96 to 1024, the perception of the sound quality with the composition of the tracks changes from a fast sensation and cleaner sound (96) to a slow sensation and a more washed out sound (1024).
Exporting this composition at a Buffer Size of 96 and 1024 then Importing them and making a null test results in a “null” at -179.7dB peak. Tool used for this measurement: Voxengo Span
Cubase looses peak meter values after -85.9dB. From -86dB it just shows infinity. (Is this an issue here?)
Normalizing the null test result between the two audio wav files back to audible range (+156dB gain) shows rhythmical noise and distortion related to the composition.
(*)composition : 6 Wav Audio Tracks overall. 4 Drum Wav Audio Tracks made of one-shot samples / 1 Bass Wav Audio Track / 1 Synth Wav Audio Track.
Q2: Does the Asio Guard when it is Deactivated still changes the sound quality with audio files only?
-Yes.
The results are the same as when Asio Guard was Activated, but there is 1 difference.
The difference between 96 buffer size and 1024 buffer size is now more clearly audible.
Meaning that Asio Guard acts like another layer on top of the Audio Interface’s buffer setting and does a similar behaviour like the audio interface’s buffer setting itself when changing it from Low to High.
With Asio Guard Activated the perception of the sound quality results in a more washed out sound.
With Asio Guard Deactivated the perception of the sound quality results in a more clear sound.
Null test result was the same.
Q3: Does the sound quality issues you hear is printed to the exported files?
-Yes.
It is printed to the exported files. Real-Time listening and Exporting/Audio Mixdown have the same sound quality differences/issues.
Meaning that it is there when listening real-time and it is there when exporting out to 1 stereo wav file.
Exporting at a buffer size of 96 with Asio Guard Activated and again exporting at a buffer size of 96 with Asio Guard Deactivated resulting in a difference exactly the same way as described above in Q2.
Side note: Disabling Automatic Hitpoint Detection does not solve any of the problems.
Very important extra note, because I found out during the testings:
-Starting an Empty Project.
-Using the Voxengo Span on the Stereo Out, hitting START/PLAY →
Span shows the basic -200dB peak/rms readout.
-Adding more Empty Audio Tracks, hitting START/PLAY →
Span shows the basic -200dB peak/rms readout.
-Filling the 1st Empty Audio Track with a Wav audio file, then MUTING IT and hitting START/PLAY →
Span still shows the -200dB readout.
-Filling the 2nd Empty Audio Track with a Wav audio file, then MUTING IT and hitting START/PLAY →
Span now shows a -194dB readout.
-Filling the 3rd Empty Audio Track with a Wav audio file, then MUTING IT and hitting START/PLAY →
Span now shows a -190.5dB readout.
-Filling 10 Empty Audio Tracks with a Wav audio file, then MUTING IT and hitting START/PLAY →
Span now shows a -180.0dB readout.
-This keeps growing bigger.
-You have to hit start/play where the audio track events are. It does not matter if it contains an audio signal or it is just plain silence there in the audio event.
-If you hit start/play where no audio events exist Span goes back to -200dB.
-Don’t rush with the test, because Span needs most of the time 12 seconds to react for the change. That 12 seconds comes from Cubase to fade out to silence somehow…
I don’t think this should be happenning. Any explanation for this?
(I’ll probably start a new topic for it, because it’s a different problem)
All Tests Performed at 44.1kHz/32bit. Win 8.1 x64 / Cubase 8.5.15 x64
Fabio, I’m going to check your project you have sent and reply to it in another post. It also takes a little more time.
-DN-