I had similar “problems” - set up my page 2001 or something, using a “what you see is what you get” webdesign application and countless nights… Redesigned 2003 or something… and 2009 or something I just deleted the page because I thought “better no page than THAT page”. Yea and it took till end of last year to put up a new page.
My first attempt was to outsource this - I am an audio dude - others are webdesigner. But I had bad success 2 times here, both times it was like “ok, we will kick of 2 of those überstunden-studiodays from the invoice and you create a cool page for me”.
To keep it short - in the end I set up a Wordpress theme with the very patient help of a good friend and filled it with content. I am not 100% happy yet as well as it is not 100% done yet - lots of stuff is missing… content… the mastering section, references, soundfiles (not sure about how to handle them, it is so complicated in Germany) etc.
But I was very unsure how I want to layout/design the page. Corporate??! Freaky?? On old days I tried to look as professional as possible without having much references… Now I have references and I could use a freaky look. I don’t know - I browsed zillions of pages… In the end I decided that it would be better to have “something” online (which looks as nice as possible) then nothing.
Not sure if this helps in any way - I would say - no )