Have you ever seen such bizarre frame fullness percentages? Except for the page size and the absence of flow headings, all of the engraving, layout and notation options are set to the factory defaults:
Nope, weird.
Jesper
The developers will probably want to see this project file.
Here is the project file:
Bizarre Frame Fullness Percentages.dorico (1.3 MB)
Interesting situation @johnkprice. Here the result experimenting with smaller Music Frame Margins (which reestablished more normal fullness values):
But certainly the negative percentage values, and the infinite red value in your example are quite peculiar ![]()
Out of your question, how can you display the red ‘frame height’ text?
I guess some of the numbers can be explained by looking at sizes and margins.
When the margins (top: 14.11 mm, bottom 10.58 mm, sum = 24.69 mm) are exactly the same as the frame height (24.69 mm for the 4th frame), the calculation will probably become some “devide by zero” problem which yields “inf%”.
When you reduze the height further, making the music frame even smaller than the configured margins, the numbers turn negative. They obviously should not be colored green then ![]()
You could just quickly download the file and have a look ![]()
Those are simple text elements attached to the first beat of the music.
Perhaps I’m being simplistic, but I think the way frame fullness should be calculated is to divide the “ideal” frame height needed to achieve a fullness of 100% by the actual height of the music frame, expressing the quotient as a percentage. Then if the actual height is twice the ideal height, the fullness would be 50%, and if the actual height is half the ideal height, the fullness would be 200%. Using this method, a fullness of infinity would only occur if the actual height was zero, and negative fullness values would be impossible.
If your glass if half full (the actual height of water is half the ideal height), would you say your glass is 200% full?
Now that’s a very strage view on the “glass is half full / half empty” problem: If the water reaches halfway up to the top, according to you, the glass is already 200% full.
And I think you are missing one important aspect: The current height of the music content.
No, because the ideal height needed to achieve a fullness of 100% would include the top and bottom music frame margins as well as the height of the music content.
Your “glass is half full” analogy is backwards. If you have 8 ounces of water, the ideal size to hold that much water is an 8-ounce glass. If you put that much water in a glass whose actual size is 16 ounces, the fullness is 50% and the glass is half full.
Oh, now I got why we lost each other.
When I say “actual height” I refer the actual height of the content of a frame after Dorico needed to compress it in order to fill the frame.
Nevermind, feel free to discard all my comments ![]()
@Estigy has helped me to realize how Dorico computes the music frame fullness. While the music content can be compressed to fit in a frame whose actual height is less than ideal, the music frame margins cannot be compressed. The factory default values for the top and bottom music frame margins are 40 and 30 points, respectively. In the example I gave in the original post, a fullness of 100% was achieved when the frame height was 80 points, leaving 10 points for the music content after subtracting the music frame margins. When the frame height was reduced to 70 points, the height left for the music content was reduced to zero, so dividing the ideal size of 10 points for the music content by the actual size of zero produced a fullness of infinity. And when the frame height was reduced to less than 70 points, the height left for the music content was less than zero, producing a negative fullness value.
So what @Estigy wrote in post #7 was completely correct.
Aw!:))) thank you! So you saved me downloading the file:) Athough your idea was so obvious!

