How To Mark A Post As Solution

Thread starters can mark a specific post as the solution (except for the Lounge Area).

Why?

  • It helps future users identify the solution as such.
  • The solution will appear right underneath the first post which speeds up the search.
  • The status in the thread list will be changed to „solved“ to inform other users that there’s a solution to the problem.
  • Marking the right post as solution also serves as a kind of „Thank You“ to acknowledge another user’s effort to help a fellow user out.

How?

More importantly, they will find a solution checkbox under each post.

All it takes is to scroll to the post that contains the actual solution and to click on the solution checkbox. In case the thread starter has accidently assigned the solution to the wrong post they can reassign the solution by simply clicking on another solution checkbox (for a limited period of time).

Which one?
The post which contains the solution or the most important aspect(s) that lead to the actual solution should be marked as such. Marking one’s own post as solution instead is usually considered bad forum etiquette!

Sometimes, it is difficult to identify a single post which contains or led to the actual solution. It might be crucial to add further information in order to understand how the solution works. It might also be the case that there is more than one post which contains parts of the solution.
It is up to the thread starter whether they want to mark the most important post as solution and supply additional information in a separate reply or if they decide to mark their own post as solution - given it contains crucial additional information. In the latter case it’s a nice gesture to mention the users (@username) who contributed to the solution and leave a like.

9 Likes

The fact that, especially in the German forum, users often mark their own final post as the solution is partly due to a lack of language skills – they simply want to mark the original question as “solved.”

How about a small addition to the forum software:
When a user wants to mark their own post as the “solution”, a dialog box could appear asking “Is this post actually the solution to the question?” (or something similar)

1 Like

Oh, good thinking - that’s a really good idea, @P.A.T !
This would indeed be a very helpful addition to forums which are mostly solution-driven like ours ( in contrast to lifestyle forums within the discourse realm).
I am not sure how to adress this request. Does it make sense to ask for this feature in the discourse forum or open a feature request here?
Again, very good idea :+1:

1 Like

Makes sense—having a confirmation prompt when marking your own post would probably prevent a lot of accidental “self-solutions.”:ok_hand::sparkles:

1 Like