do yu mean 5 votes every month or every year or forever only 5 votes ?. i see also other usefull features have less votes
Forever. But I think you can undo the ones youāve used and put them somewhere else.
Whether theyāre actually used by SB to gauge what to give attention to, who knows! ![]()
I get the idea for better midi plugin support. maybe this is in C 12 possible ?. cubase have rack in which i can load a instrument vst. so my idea is .can i use a instrument track and on this track can route the midi output of the scaler for example to a rack slot so the instrument on the rack output the sound ?.
use a rack and in the track is the midi plugin is much better as use 1 track for midi effect, other track for instrument. so there happen no problems on activate for realtime play
there actually is a third-party VST-MA pluginā¦
you have to install the .dll into components folder and appear as midi inserts
Franks Midi plugins
Hi, I would like to add some different midi plugins, do you know if they will work if they are not those from franks?
can you tell us the steps to install them?
thanks!
A. I would love to see a midi modular environment similar to Bidule as midi inserts as is Arpache, Transformer, Frankās ⦠This Midi Modular Environment will be able to host VSTi midi fx and have a midi in and a midi out. This way one can easily use the third party midi fx. This way one can go on using the Cubase midi fx and if they wish they can ignore the Modular Environment. For me I would always use the Modular Environment. ![]()
B. Better yet put all the Cubase midi fx in a Modular Environment similar to Bidule and allow it to host third party VSTi midi fx. This way one will be able connect the Cubase midi fx and the third party VSTi midi fx in any way they desire.
![]()
edit:
Steinberg can ask the developers of Bidule, Element etc. to develop a modular environment in the āCubase Midi Insertā format and offer it for sale or even better yet offer it for free (Let Steinberg pay them).
Would be awesome if they finally would integrate 3rd party midi fx support for the midi insertsā¦![]()
Matthias, where can we ask for this to be looked upon? there are some good midi plugins that could make our life easier.
Is there a way to open the midi inserts to third party plugins?
thanks!
signed
The assumption that itās not possible to use or develop third party midi plug ins is not correct.. You can still develop midi plug ins for Cubase/Nuendo and I am doing it right now with some agentic AI help and it works. Not sure though about Steinberg willing to pay third party for developing midi plug ins and giving them for free.
I assumed it was not possible, and a couple of plugin makers told me so, do you have more info about it?
Care to expand on this?
Can I raise this topic again. This is another feature request that is so old itās had time to leave school, grow a beard and raise a familyā¦
I have useful VST3 MIDI inserts that would be helpful to me in Cubase, yet STILL no way to use them. Today I could have done with using my āMPE to poly aftertouchā processor, but no dice.
Itās time this one was sorted out. Nobody wants a different plug-in format for MIDI inserts, Steinberg - surely youāve figured that out by now? Only your own plug-ins are in that meagre list.
Yes, support for 3rd party midi fx is needed.
Iāll add to the list of people wishing for this. Unfortunately Steinberg has at times stated that VST is not a midi plugin spec, despite some people use it that way, their intention is for it to be audio. The midi in (and out) was only added from the beginning to support VST instruments. But so many people have made so many great midi pluginsā¦that it really canāt be ignored, and while they have somewhat begrudgingly updated VST3 over time to make sure people stop complaining about they still to this day do not support hosting VST3 midi plugins directly in the instrument channel. LogicPro is the best example of a DAW that provides this capability with AUmfx plugin support in instrument channels. That is what I wish Steinberg would add also, but weāve been asking for this for a very long time and it never makes the list, and as I said, I donāt think its in their long term vision of how VST should be used in general.
The old midi plugins, like Frankās, I would love to know more about that, I tried to look into getting that SDK a long time ago an had problems getting it or any help figuring it out, but I would consider vibe coding some solutions if there was better support for it.
While it is possible to route tracks to other tracks thereby getting midi plugin processing from track to trackā¦each jump to a new track loses sample accuracy as the timestamps are reset on each routing across tracks. Itās basically not sample accurate midi processing that way if you care. Some midi tasks donāt matter like if youāre just playing around with Scaler3 or something but if you are actually trying to lay down an arpegiator line or step sequencer or whateverā¦the timing will not be sample accurate when processed that way. For now the only way to have sample accurate midi timing through midi plugins in Cubase is to use a third party hoster such as Patchwork or a few others put both the midi plugin(s) and instrument into a single instrument plugin slot of cubaseā¦those will handle things sample accurately, so that is better then the kludgy track routing that people have done for years in Cubase to get around this.
This is old I knowā¦but there are so many hardware surfaces that do basic stuff but more than thatā¦just learn to play them. I dont use any midi now but did for a couple of decadesā¦I used the paz midi I think it wasā¦but steinberg plugs covered all of that
My advice is to stop looking to machines to do it for youā¦learn to play and your music will feel way betterā¦sure use tools to tweak if you must but the journey is half the enjoyment. Get yourself a good controller like HPD20ā¦sure it will take time to learn to play but the human response and expression will reward you. It even has positional.
Drum editor for doing the machine stuff is where I startedā¦it hasnt changed a lot since 1988 but did you know you can simply use some of the other midi phrase plugs and just build your rolls in that in any edited way you want, with eg filter controllers and cc for modelled parameters eg attack, pitch drum decay etc so rolls actually sound larger that life and just play the phrase? Way deeper and all the tools are already thereā¦just think differently
MPE is a diff story but cant say i have heard any amazing music that uses itā¦please point me to itā¦like the Roli stuff (now dead)ā¦what does it actually mean to songs and listeners?
This of course assumes the person is physically capable of playing an instrument. Or even has an interest in doing so. Plus many very popular music genres are built on mechanical precision.
Have you considered the possibility that some, perhaps most, of the people who would like to see MIDI Plugins are also quite capable players. Itās not mutually exclusive.
Hi @raino
This is implicit. I work in disability support doing industrial design for someone I now consider my friend not just a client. The op did not mention anything like this
As per the OP actual applicationā¦Im a percussionist (now after 15 years of playing)ā¦Im just sharing my experience of
- Cubase has enough bare bones tools framework to fulfil so much of midi needā¦just not in an instant grat overlay
2. In the case of rollsā¦it can actually do this very easily and well so in this application, just seek and you will find
3.Im sharing personal experience that yes, is antithetical to much of todays culture but is so rewarding when the integration of humanity and music meet in midi
4.The application of the ārollā plugin suggests realtime playingā¦so unless you are doing insane machine 64ths leading to a drop in EDM or somethingā¦laterally thinking in Cubase using the very capable tools only improves your creativity instead of having a toolbox of 15 plugins to choose fromā¦could it do with the addition of a midi plug spec? Sure but its not imperative ime
A midi 2 spec that included a generic framework? Im not against Cubase getting better just found it so aheadā¦think back to v1 on atari and the IPSā¦that thing was brilliant but you can do most of it modular with what is alread there
The forum is about sharingā¦I might not agree with some of the stuff because Im blessed with enough experience to know that there is no substitute for humanity and connectionā¦the best music has that ime but I admit that the charts of the last 10 years to not attest to that.
Im not dissing midi, the use of electronicaā¦some of my faves are eg kraftwerk, new order etcā¦but creating in that way forced the same thing that Im talking about now
Peace
using my vote hereā¦
15 votes! Letās get it cooking Steinberg!
We should consolidate our votes to this feature request and a main thread for it. I am betting there are some scattered out there on the same request.
