Is this OK?

Hello Friends,

I’am writing a piece, you can see in this example, flute 4#, soprano sax 6# and altsax 5b.
According me it must be 7# for the alto sax?
Is this a problem in Dorico?

Who can help me?

Thanks for help!

Bernard (the Netherlands)

Dorico is choosing Db M instead of C# because of this Notation Option:

If you untick it, you should get 7 sharps.

6 Likes

5 flats for the alto sax is Db major, which is enharmonically equivalent to C# major (7 sharps). So what you have there is not wrong.

If you’d prefer to see 7 sharps, one solution is to go to Notation Options > Accidentals > Transposition and untick “Prefer enharmonic equivalent key signatures with fewer accidentals”. Note that this will apply to all instruments in the flow.

(Ninja’d by @charles_piano!)

4 Likes

Maybe before following this excellent advice you should talk to your sax players.

Most that I know would prefer D-flat major rather than C-sharp.

8 Likes

Ofcourse, thanks for help and wish you a nice weekend!
Bernard

Met vriendelijke groet,

Bernard Klopman
06 2249 6315

Verzonden vanaf Outlook voor Android

1 Like

@bklopman You might want to remove your phone number from this public forum.

3 Likes

Thanks Aaron. I’ve changed it, but can’t remove it in the sent mail​:face_with_peeking_eye:

You should be able to edit your post on the forum itself. I don’t think the e-mail you sent is relevant anymore.

1 Like

Change it in your post here

As a sax player, I’d prefer a different key altogether! :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:

4 Likes