Hi everyone,
I have a specific issue: tied notes show accidentals under microtonal trills. I have a screenshot and I also attached an example file.
Can you reproduce this issue? Is it a bug or am I missing something?
Thank you
Tolga
Trill-tie problem.dorico (1.4 MB)
A trill over a tie is a single trill (since the tied note is a single object).
A trill over three notes creates a new trill on each
Hi Janus,
Exactly. You perfectly summarized the issue.
So why am I seeing in m.1 two extra A quarter flats after the first one?
Likely because the trill is with an A-natural.
My guess is they are cautionaries due to the auxiliary A natural, which is implied. Where in your second example the auxiliary has changed so only one cautionary is needed.
Here is the problem: Second example is the exact copy of first example only untied. I did not put in B quarter flats. It turns out Dorico did.
I’m guessing it’s because the default for a trill is up a whole step or the next note up in the key signature where possible. With three untied notes, the first would be what you input, but without input on the following two, Dorico uses the default. If you want the tie without the additional cautionary symbols, you could probably turn those off in the bottom panel.
I do agree. But since Dorico produces them as trill continuation I cannot turn them off. I have no control over them even if I untie them and try to manipulate them one by one. I attached the example file in my original post. If anyone can come up with a way to get rid of the unnecessary cautionaries, I’ll be grateful.
I got the effect you’re looking for by hiding the individual accidentals in Engrave mode. Works just fine there. I could hide the last accidental in Write mode, but not the second. Since Engrave mode is your last step in the process, this should be your solution until there’s a good way to hide individual cautionary accidentals under a tie in Write mode.
Yes. That worked. Thank you.
