Noteperformer 5 (maybe) something wrong?

good afternoon guys,

I can see that there is already a post on this but it hasn’t helped me, so I figured I’d do my own.

About three days ago I bought noteperformer 5 as I was very impressed with how it sounded on other people’s projects. Immediately after installing, I noticed that the first thing it did was make my piece (exclusively for strings) sound like it was played by brass instruments. I followed AI advice and they told me to go into the playback template and set it to silence and then reset again to noteperformer.

Although on one level this sorted it out, it now sounds like the instruments are very ‘MIDI’ and synthetic, not like the noteperformer examples I saw online. AI told me to look into the Dorico mixer and see if dorico’s compression and Reverence reverb were on, which they were and so i turned them off, which seemed to help a bit, but I am still feeling that something is off. I have also turned the ‘humanize’ down to 10 percent, as it felt like there was too much vibrato, but again the issue is not completely solved.

Its important to note that everything might be fine, I might just be underwhelmed by the software, but I just need to know for a fact so I can stop worrying about it!

I have given up on being helped by AI and think its about time I spoke to people who actually knew what they were talking about!

For the record, I have reduced noteperfomer reverb to 32 and have noteperformer volume on around 95- so i don’t think its anything to do with noteperformer settings. I have resent playback overrides a number of times, and also, when i try and switch back to halion under VST instruments- nothing happens. This might not be relevant but thought id give as much info as poss!

many thanks for your help

Can you upload a short project that sounds wrong to you?

Some folks consider strings to be the weakest of NP’s instrument renditions.

piece 1 IN 3.dorico (469.5 KB)

thank you!

On my system, this sounds the way I would expect it to, for better or worse!

The instruments sound as I would expect. Certainly not Brass instruments. Overall it is flat and stilted because you have not added any dynamic variation or phrasing (which NotePerformer will interpret).

Here’s the opening without any adjustment…

Sounds pretty good coming from scoring software here.

If you’re unhappy with the phrasing and dynamics at this state, check out the settings in “Library/Play Back Options”. The documentation for NP has some suggestions on these settings, and of course you can refine them a bit for various needs.

You can also add various markings to your score to affect the phrasing and dynamics as well (hide them if you feel it’s self explanatory stuff to a real musician, and don’t want it to be seen).

As for the quality of the sounds themselves…you can get better stuff, but it’ll be quite expensive, and will require much extra work on your part to use and get it phrasing and articulating.

The main value of NP is thus far, it’s the only product that we can simply load and pretty much forget, plus get decent automatic interpretation of phrasing, dynamics, and the more common articulations and note value markings.

I.E. One can get the stuff that is included with Dorico to sound very nice, and pretty realistic, but it requires a lot of manual instrument browsing, tweaking sounds, fiddling with expression maps, and staging whatever kind of mix you want.

NP isn’t as ‘flexible’ as the stuff that comes with Dorico in terms of the kind of mix and balance users might want, but what what it does do is pick a standard environment across the board, balance, gain-stage, and pan every instrument in the library towards a standard seating configuration, ambience/room/environment, mic placements, and provide a respectable score interpretation and overall mix with minimal user intervention. All one needs to do is make a player or section stave in Dorico and start composing.

Getting results that come closer to, or exceed what NP offers with virtually zero extra user intervention can take quite a chunk of time just staging and roughing in a tolerable mix with other libraries; hence, the popularity of NP with Dorico, Sibelius, and Finale.

Somebody spent a tremendous amount of time ‘staging’ every instrument for us, so we don’t have to mess with it.

What exactly sounds off about your NP experience? Are you using super sensitive flat monitoring equipment in a well designed setup (right distance from speakers, treated room, etc), or something else? Headphones maybe?

I.E. I have a nice set of monitors, but bad placement and a horrible room. I can’t even detect reverb half the time, but I play it through my headphones or the cheap computer desk speakers and all the sudden it is SWIMMING in reverb. Over time I’ve learned how my poor monitoring situation will ‘translate’ to things like my head-phones, the car stereo, etc. In my case, it’s not really the speakers, nor is it the software and stuff that’s the problem. It’s my awful room and speaker placement relative to where I sit (and for the time being, I can’t change it).

When it comes to library demonstrations that we click and listen to on the web/cloud…it seems to me like they’ve undergone at least some ‘mastering’ level adjustments to compress and enhance the right things so it’ll translate better on a wide variety of speakers. Seems to me on my system that when played ‘off of a stream on Youtube or whatever’, it’s never as harish and exposed sounding as when I’m actually working directly ‘In DAW’. Even if the author who put the stuff on some streaming service didn’t do any mastering process before uploading, it’s just smoother and better blended for some reason…sometimes the servers do it ‘for them’ through a server side process. Things automatically get optimized a bit for the ‘stream’ there.

I’ve noticed that to make it less harish when I’m working with something like Dorico, I need to set up some EQs and maybe small amount of compression in Dorico to avoid listener fatigue while I’m working. If I intend to render a master that could get played out in the wild…I go for totally different settings before rendering…and if I have time might even load it up in Wavelab and try things with different speakers, headphones, ear buds, etc, before deciding on what to share or publish.

thanks for your response!

Maybe I wasn’t clear, but after I reset the playback template the instruments stopped sounding like brass but still sounded a little ‘off’ to me! But it seems as though everything is in order- thank you for your feedback!

thank you!

thanks very much for such a detailed response- I will bear all this in mind!

thanks!

it’s exactly how I would expect the NotePerfomer strings to sound which is why I’d never dream of using them in a mock-up. Sometimes reducing the vibrato level can help (CC105) a bit but it can only take you so far. The only decent NotePerfomer mock-ups I have heard are ones with lively articulated music where strings play a subordinate role. Arne Wallander himself has said that the point of NP is to give a decent proofing took for assessing instrumental balance and in that it succeeds reasonably well.

The real point of NotePerfomer used to be in my opinion, the plug-ins of the NP Performance Engine where you could combine proper sample libraries with something of NP’s musical intelligence. Unfortunately, these were withdrawn after it’s suspected some company threatened legal action but to me this was throwing the baby out with the bathwater. Never mind - the plug-ins still work with NP 4.5. I do hope that the actual sounds improve as there is nothing significantly better in v5 to compensate for the loss of NPPE. Of course some disagree but there it is. It looks like AI has been rejected as a way forward for the library so it will indeed be interesting to see where it goes from here.

Is it just me or … are these string sounds not as effective as those which come bundled with Dorico Pro? In which case, what’s the value proposition of NotePerformer?

(Not asking this as a diss. I’ve never used NP and am genuinely interested in whether it might be worth incorporating into my workflows.)

In general NP’s instrument balance and almost turnkey approach to VST sounds is very convenient, inexpensive, and reasonably good for most instruments it supports. One should not judge NP’s sounds by its strings.

except that the strings are the heart of the majority of orchestral pieces. But I know many are wedded to NP and either are wiling to overlook its sonic deficiencies or simply find it too much effort to use something else (above all Sibelius or Finale users where support for third party VST’s is far less good than Dorico).

And as for @joseph.wakeling question – well he will have to decide for himself. I admit that from being reasonably enthusiastic about NP when there was less competition in affordable sample libraries and even more enthusiastic when NPPE came along, I’ve become increasingly disillusioned. Which doesn’t mean there is not still a place for the library, depending on exactly what you’re looking for.