"Notes and rests" engraving tools ease of use

I’m currently finalizing a big score for performance, and I’m running into some major mechanics that slow me down considerably.

Sometimes, I want to select multiple bars to for example hide all accidentals at once. To do this, I select the first note and the last note of the passage by holding shift. However, this selects other elements that makes the “notes and rests” category in the lower zone disappear in engraving mode. This is one annoyance that I don’t understand why it is a function. However, I thought, easy fix: just filter on notes and rests! However, still no bueno, because this also selects the tuplet notations, making the aforementioned area disappear in engraving mode. My only options here is to manually select, or deselect. all the objects I need without making any mistakes, which is quite hard and time-consuming to do in a large score where many edits and adjustments are needed.

Is there a reason that the different categories disappear in the lower zone engrave mode based on what you have selected? I suppose it could be to make things clean and less cluttered, but it is quite annoying that tools that you need handy are disappearing based on very slight selection mistakes and such. I’d rather have all the tools where I expect them to be, all the time.

And furthermore, and this is a personal pipe dream I realize: I need the option to hide accidentals, hide notes, etc. practically all the time. It is extremely time consuming to be switching between writing and engraving mode every time I need these tools, especially in large scores and when you write in galley mode.

I really enjoy Dorico, but things like these are making me reconsider why I switched from my previous software, which was mostly based on giving you all the tools you need, all the time, as quickly as possible. Now I find myself continuously interrupting my creative workflow to do very specific things simply to get a button to appear in the lower zone.

The way to do it is, Filter (select) by Notes and Chords, then switch the filter to deselect Grace Notes and also Tuplets.

1 Like

In some cases there are keyboard shortcuts available to hide things from write mode. Accidentals, noteheads, and stems specifically. These commands are also accessible from the jumpbar.

Some things (like time signatures) can be hidden with the show/hide item command.

what’s left are the options common to everything you’ve selected.

agreed, it’s also highly inconsistent in regards to which things can be hidden in Write Mode, and which can be hidden only in Engrave Mode.

that’s the MuseScore approach - you’ll get the full range of opinions here on whether that’s a good thing.

In the meantime you could do worse than copy the approach to filter shortcuts given here Difficulty selecting notes in a chord - #14 by MarcLarcher - this has lowered my stress levels considerably

1 Like

I know this approach doesn’t work for everyone, or in all situations, but you might also consider altering your workflow so that you input all the raw musical content first, in Write mode, and then switch to Engrave mode at the end to adjust the way it looks. Even doing this section by section would reduce the number of mode switches.

2 Likes