When trying to nudge objects by 1 bar in 5/4 and 6/4, Cubase doesn’t function properly. It only nudges it by 4 beats, the first push, then by the remainder the second push. This requires two nudges instead of one, which throws off everyone’s key commands and messes up my workflow.
Not sure if it would further mess with your work flow, but the only way I could get it to nudge a full bar of 5/4 is to set Nudge to “Link to Grid” and set the “Grid Type” to Bar. Any other combo (1/1 for nudge or Quantize (if grid type = "Use Quantize) resulted in the behavior you are seeing… Thinking the 1/1 should mean 1 bar regardless of Time Sig…
Edit: It appears that 1/1 equates to 4 beats and the actual time signature is ignored.
So, 1/1 works for a bar of 3/4, it nudges it 3 beats instead of 4, and for 2/4 as well. It’s just when there are more than 4 beats per bar, it will nudge by 4 beats for the first nudge, then the remainder for the second nudge.
Your right, with 3/4 (and Lower) and Q set to 1/1. Grid set to Use Quantize, and Nudge set to Link to grid, it nudges 1 full bar, but over 4/4 then the issue occurs. Must have not used that configuration while testing it.
If I select a note length value of 1/1, be it for quantize, nudging or anything, I expect the 1/1 value to represent a whole note / semibreve:
So If I select 1/1 for the purpose of nudging, and see a nudge of a full bar in a 3/4 time signature, then that is the bug in my mind.
Quantize or note length values has never been a fraction of a full bar/measure.
A measure in 5/4 is comprised of 5 beats of quarter notes. A full measure could be composed with 5 quarter notes (5 * 1/4) or one whole note plus one quarter note (1/1 + 1/4).
5/4 ≠ 1/1
This is an interesting behaviour. Taking into account that:
a) This only occurs with Snap Type set to Quantize
b) This behaviour is consistent for ALL quantize values when a nudge step would bring the cursor OVER a barline. (For example, set signature to 3/4. 1/1 will nudge bars, 1/2 will first go to 3 and then to the next bar’s 1, and not 2. In 6/4 time, 1/1 will go to 5, and then to the next bar’s 1, not 4. In 11/8 time, nudging 1/2 will take us to the 5th eighth, the 9th eighth, and then to the 1 of the next bar.)
c) There exists a key command especially for the purpose of nudging bars (Transport → Nudge +1 Bar and Transport → Nudge -1 Bar) that works regardless of Snap Type setting or time signature.
I would offer that this is not a bug. It’s a feature. Unexpected? Yes. Surprising? Yes. But I think it’s useful, in the sense that it respects bars.
@audiohead75 The official way is to file a support ticket afaik. If you’re lucky, a Steiny rep or forum mod might notice the “issue” tag and file it for you, but it’s not guaranteed.