Question about ties and accidentals

If the last note in a bar is a flat (Eb for example) and it is tied to the first note of the next bar which is also an E, is it played as Eb or natural?

Eb

Jesper

1 Like

Ties always join notes of the same pitch (including enharmonic equivalents).

4 Likes

Although see Library > Notation Options > Accidentals, especially Second Viennese School Options, for more illumination of Dorico’s flexibility in cases where that flat is an accidental.

1 Like

And why? Because the definition of a tie is that it means the second note is not struck or sounded but continues the initial note. So the note cannot be different. You may be thinking of a slur, which has the same appearance.

2 Likes

Also, with respect, ‘Question’ is not a good topic title in Discourse as it gives no clue as to what the topic is about. Even ‘Tie question’ would be better. But I am not the moderator so I better shush! :slight_smile:

3 Likes