At least,in Cubase 15.0.30 the bug was resolved.
Are there existing files in the media pool folder?
Not sure about this 'cause according the internal bugbase, the bug is not fixed in 15.0.30.
Fredo
No. Recently lost a bunch of used events in the project by hitting “Remove unused media”. Very nasty bug, and it’s still not fixed in the latest releases of Cubase/Nuendo
I’ve been struggling with this bug since C14 was released, on my systems they were fixed the same day I installed 15.0.30 (there’s at least one thread where my frustration died when these things happened, Steinbeeg knows I’ve been hard on them, and with reason).
it is a function that I use daily and since the last update it has NOT happened.
my temporary solution was to use cubase 13 for the edits and use of that function, then the rest, the latest version of cubase. It was the only solution at the time.
I think you must be mixing up things, or talking about a different bug.
The reality is that it is not fixed in 15.0.30 and that it works perfectly in N14.
HTH
Fredo
I’m talking about the same mistake you named “removing unused media”, or “emptying the pool”
as I said،this was in Cubase. I don’t have Nuendo, and I can’t try it.
There is absolutely no difference between Cubase and Nuendo.
Fredo
Anybody knows if this was fixed in the latest update (.40)? I see nothing about it in the release notes
Stuff broken in updates needs to be fixed post-haste in a speedy new update, taking priority over new stuff. Because this disrupts established workflows, breaks macros, and damages projects. The .40 update took far too long, and did not address urgent breakages. IMHO.
I would add that putting off critical bug fixes erodes confidence, sends people looking for safer alternatives. Doesn’t matter if Nuendo is your most favorite DAW if it causes you to lose work. That’s a deal-breaker in any industry.
I’ll repeat what I wrote earlier here and elsewhere: this website really needs a section with technical alerts.
We need a section where serious issues are listed along with the repro that makes the issue occur.
How am I supposed to trust this feature in any way when not only isn’t it fixed, but there also is no clear repro for it!?
This plus AAF imported events moving to full scale in some situations plus DOP still being messed up is just too much I think. How is the software still containing these issues after all this time.
And that’s exactly where the problem is. The developers (and other testers) have done everything to identify the problem, but couldn’t reproduce it. I’ve send my projects, tried to reproduce it myself, but without luck. So if anyone has a clear case… Please let us know.
Fredo
Hello Joe,
Just update to 15 from 14, must choose minimize at the backup project window? can’t choose remove unused media at the point?
sorry don’t fully understand your question? I normally chose minimise file when running a backup project yes
Sorry, let me explain in a bit more detail.
In Nuendo 14, due to a bug, I usually selected “Remove Unused Media” when creating a backup project to reduce the project size.
Has this bug become worse in Nuendo 15? Does it also affect the “Remove Unused Media” option when creating a backup project?
Based on my experience, using this option when creating a backup project does not delete any media files that are still being used.
Also, may I ask why you choose “Minimize” instead of “Remove Unused Media”?
So “removed unused media” will only shrink your file size down if you also ask it to erase the files on your drive (I personally never do that with an ongoing project just to be safe). When a project is shipped and approved (QC included) I use the backup project option with minimise file (this then will only keep the section of the even used in a project and create new smaller files), I also select removed unused media, and make offline permanent as well. This is exclusively for archive purposes to to keep file size down after a project is completed.
In terms of N15 becoming worse, no not really just a few of us seemed to have encountered the above mention bug (OP’s message) but unfortunately its not reproducible and if any consolation i’ve been using it again in N15 (carefully) and it seems to work properly as far as I can tell with the latest version
I’ve been experiencing this issue since Nuendo 10. It became relatively less frequent in Nuendo 14, and I also found a workaround to avoid triggering it.
During a project, I often need to import Track Archives or entire projects sent by other people. Deleting the original source files afterward has a fairly high chance of triggering this issue. However, I can’t keep all those original files indefinitely, as they take up too much storage space.
That’s why I periodically use Backup Project to make sure all the required media files are properly copied into the project folder. Once I’ve confirmed that, I can safely delete the original source files.
I just want to make sure that this workflow is still safe and reliable in Nuendo 15.
Just used again on a large project with a lot of unused media and sadly it happened again. So will do the N14 trick for now and make a note to report this session when I can to the devs. May be connected to external / or missing files in the session when running this not sure.
I wonder, if this is still a problem in V16 of the DAW.