Spectralayers vs suno studio

SpectraLayers
1

I did some tests and I’m shocked. The latest “Spectralayers 12 Pro” separate tracks worse than Suno Studio.

1 Like
2

care to expand your findings?

for which instruments achieve better separation?

and what of other sounds?

did you only test music?

3

Why are you shocked? Every time you use the Suno service you grant them full ownership of your work. Specifically:

By using the Service or transmitting Submissions, you grant Suno, its affiliates, successors, assigns, and designees a worldwide, non-exclusive, fully paid-up, sublicensable, assignable, royalty-free, perpetual, irrevocable license to use, reproduce, store, modify, distribute, create derivative works from, perform, display, communicate, transmit and otherwise make available any and all “Content” (both your Submissions and the resulting Output) in any media, in connection with:

  • Providing and operating the Service;

  • Monetizing, promoting, and marketing Suno’s products and services;

  • Training, developing, fine-tuning or otherwise improving the Service and related AI/ML models.

Given they literally own every single bit of content any user ever creates, it’s not surprising they can pour extraordinary resources into development, right? I mean, if people were handing me free money I’d ensure the mechanics of the service enabling monetization was funded properly too.

That said, I can’t actually verify any claims of algorithmic superiority for any specific purpose as I wouldn’t ever even consider using such a service; but that’s only because I don’t want to give away my intellectual property just to use their service.

4

folks could record some basic musical exercises; layer it all up and send some mixes in, just to investigate the capability…no need submit your precious children

1 Like
5

I recommend to experiment with different stem separation models on the Internet because, of course, SpectraLayers isn’t the best in every category but it’s still very usable.

For example, I get a lot better vocal/instrumental separation with ensembled bs-roformer models in Ultimate Vocal Remover than with SpectraLayers itself.

Websites like MVSEP.com also have a lot of different stem separation models for instrument categories that SpectraLayers doesn’t offer. And it’s even free to use and made by enthusiasts.

2 Likes