Turn beaming off for vocal staves

I wan’t intending to argue against Dorico having a syllabic feature either, since it is certainly needed for critical editions and such. The OP seemed to be dealing with his own original material, and I was commenting on that.

@L3B I’m glad you had the Arnstein experience! He did classes at Juilliard for one, maybe elsewhere. Not sure.

I still find beaming to syllables useful for notating certain types of recitative in a score in which the rest of the vocal writing is beamed to the beat. Apart from all else, it makes the distinction unequivocal. However, I presume that in Dorico it would be easy to override the relevant beaming (if there is not too much of it).

In this 315 page score (in Finale) from 2012, I think I may have only two instances of such notation…

It would seem simple enough to select all the notes in a vocal part (or recitative section) and then right-click to choose “split beams.” Then one would only have to restore the melismas, which one would have to handle separately anyway were Dorico to supply a feature to separate beamed notes.

The feature request here (and elsewhere) would be a beaming according to the lyrics system (i.e. it beams notes when there are hyphens or extender lines, and splits the beams between syllables.) Finale used to offer this (I’m not sure about Sibelius).

It is. There’s a number of commands available from the right click menu, the Edit menu, the Jump Bar or via custom keyboard shortcuts. Especially using the latter, it’s a very quick, albeit still manual process. Presumably that’s also why the developers don’t feel much pressure in adding the automatic function getting requested here: everything it would do is already very doable.

:light_bulb:Since when has this feature been available in Finale? Thanks for the tip!
:see_no_evil_monkey:I’ve never noticed it; I’ve always done it by hand in Finale too.

I started using Finale around 2005, and I think it was already implemented (I’ve used it quite a lot since then).

I have key shortcuts for Beam Together (Opt X) and Split Beaming (X), which makes it very easy to split the whole lot and rebeam where required. (X by default is a keyboard zoom, but I have no need for it.)

At least since version 3 (1994)

I haven’t heard his name mentioned for decades. I also studied with him. Working on Broadway back in the pen and ink days, some of his practices were later dropped (like including numeral “1” over a whole rest) but almost all the copyists I worked with had studied with him. Thanks for jarring the memory.

You are welcome @rawmuse! When I worked for him during the 70s, he was doing mostly operas and concert music.

If true—and I find that believable—then it’s really a matter of obstructionism more than anything else. “You certainly have the ability to change things, but we won’t make it easy for you, and you’ll have to change them one by one. You can speed it up, but you still can’t do everything all at once.” (Even though Finale and, yes, Sibelius both have this feature, so it can’t be too hard to implement.)

I must also second @eebiggs1 in calling out the “I never use that so why include it” sentiment. And yes, I’ve seen that happen multiple times with multiple different requested features.

I’ve seen this argument before. Leaving aside that that’s not what a slur is supposed to be for, I must respectfully disagree. Consider this example in nonsyllabic beaming…

…and the same example in syllabic beaming…

I submit that the second example is much easier to parse lyrically, especially at speed. New beaming = new syllable (which I think is the real reason syllabic beaming emerged, not ambiguity of position) is a much easier rule to follow than hunting for a slur that might not even be there. (It’s not as if Dorico automatically provides syllabic slurs, either.) If the rhythm is truly considered too complicated (and I don’t think this one is, especially in proper context), I’ve also seen dotted barlines (at the half note or at the quarter note) used as a compromise.

The trouble with this argument is that it doesn’t apply to larger note values without flags/beams.

If that entire passage was made of quarter notes, would you say it was difficult to read, without some other indication of the melisma?

And that is exactly what slurs are for. Here’s an early 18th-century manuscript, where because he can’t beam over the barline, he’s used a slur to show the melisma.

Slurs are used to show melismas in countless scores from the 17th century onwards, particularly to show melismas in longer note values.

True, but only in addition to syllabic beaming, not replacing it. I’m not against using slurs, particularly where they would be otherwise justified (e.g., phrasing within an especially long melisma, which is what I first had in mind). Notice also how the next syllable after your example does not have a slur and remains beamed separately from the preceding eighth note.

And the rhythm is nigh unintelligible without scanning the whole line ahead of time, whereas you can glance at the first example and see it is two measures of straight 16ths in an instant and know you simply need to pay attention to text placement.

One of the additional issues with the second example is that the spacing is all over the place because of the various widths of the lyrics. The consequence is your eye sees larger gaps and thinks they might be 8ths, for instance, but they aren’t. It’s a nightmare to parse the rhythms.

This is a good example of the superiority of “ancient” human music engravers.

The Mozart reference edition, Bärenreiter – Don Giovanni was released in 1968 – takes the spacing into account.

As I mentioned in one of my earlier posts, it’s also a matter of long-standing habit especially for Europeans..

And I’d like to repeat the unit comparison: Americans will never abandon inches, feet and miles in favor of centimeters, meters and kilometers even it’s so much easier to read convert. :wink:

The reason that Dorico doesn’t yet have this feature is that in order to make it work automatically, it requires the “beamifier” (the engine responsible for determining beam groupings) to be aware of lyrics, and for edits to lyrics to cause the beams to be recalculated, which is not as simple as it might sound.

I don’t know whether Finale ever did this fully automatically, but Sibelius certainly didn’t: you had to remember to run a plug-in to do it. Our goal in Dorico is never to leave you relying on remembering to do something before you finish a project. Instead, it should be possible to set up an option so that Dorico will maintain your preferences automatically without you having to think about it. That does, unfortunately, make things lots more complicated, and our approach of trying not to add half-baked features means that we typically won’t attempt something until we can be sure we can do it properly.

Thanks for this interesting explanation. Indeed, in Finale there was no real‑time calculation: if you changed the lyrics, you had to reapply the feature (it was typically something you were doing at the end).

(emphasis mine) I understand this as meaning that the team is searching for a way to make this automatic, presumably as a Notation Option (in the Beam Grouping category). Many of us would have settled for the Finale/Sibelius-style plug-in treatment or at least haven’t specifically asked for an automatic solution. But I agree that an automatic solution would be preferable—indeed, the Dorico way. And I’m glad that that is what the team would rather do—an improvement over the way other notation programs do/did this.

I don’t know how that might happen, of course, but I’m imagining it as a matter of conditional formatting, similar to my previous comment: if there’s a new syllable, the beam is split at that location (in the same manner as the “Split Beam” manual command). I’ve never seen syllabic beaming make notes beamed that would otherwise be unbeamed, so at least the changes go in only one direction. That’s presumably the Finale/Sibelius solution; making this adapt to changes automatically is a different question, of course.

Incidentally, the question of revising lyrics, which I hadn’t previously considered, is yet another reason I favor syllabic beaming in principle. If this were automatic, the change in beaming would (again per my previous comment) be much more quickly and easily spotted than the repositioning of the text or even the repositioning of a slur.