UR44 Output 3 only sends DSP reverb wet

Hey everyone. Not sure what I’m missing here. Recording dry guitar from a POD HD processor to input 1 while direct monitoring inputs 3/4 for the wet tone.

Routing that dry signal to output 3 and into the POD’s line input. When I play back, all I hear is the dry signal, through the DSP reverb on the UR going through my amp tone. Any idea where I’m going wrong? Thanks!

PS I’m not using Cubase, so I’m able to just use the DSP MIx utility alongside my DAW.