Hi. Congratulations on finally catching up with Melodyne.
It will be even better if you apply some improvements.
I would like the left / right movement of the note freely. If you want to move the note or adjust the beat, you have to pull the end of each note one by one to set it off.
Do not empty the vocal breath. The big problem is that VariAudio does not recognize words like breath sounds. Breath sounds should be freely editable.
A vertical grid of 8 bits or less is required. Please keep the key editor grid for detailed editing.
Tripple/dotted grid snap is not possible because of the above problem.
A visual volume change indication is required when adjusting the volume.
When adjusting the volume, it should be able to adjust the degree of smoothness of the dissolve between the notes. Melodyne allows you to adjust the smoothness of the volume and pitch between the notes, so you can naturally connects between notes, no matter how hard you Transform notes. (Please watch this video : - YouTube)
I can hear the note when clicking on it; be sure you have the acoustic feedback button pressed in the Toolbar at top of the Editor window.
Also, your number 5 is a MUST have.! If they can adjust the background waveform image horizontally when warping segments (notes/words) to reflect the changes, surely it can’t be too hard to show an increase/decrease in height of the waveform for amplitude changes.
Also - please, please…!
Allow CTRL+ALT+mouse-drag, for free-zooming with the zoom tool (meaning vertical and horizontal movement depending on how you drag). See Melodyne’s use if you need convincing - its killer-quick in helping navigation.! The current Zoom works horizontally ONLY with the zoom tool, and is really debilitating. We’ve got to have easier vertical zooming control.!
Please add double-clicking in free space to start/stop playback; yes, I know I can now use SHIFT+ALT and click to place the playhead… but it is just such a killer move to have double-click to allow placement AND to start playback - at the same time.!! It makes for a wicked quick workflow.
To adjust the volume and beat of the breath. In detail, since VariAudio treats the breath sounds completely differently, there is a problem that only the breath is excluded from adjusting the overall beat and volume with other notes. Of course you can see the disappearing area with Ctrl + drag, but it is not possible to edit the breath sounds into individual notes. Perhaps it is because I am too adapted to edit the breath with melodyne.
I’ve tried everything to change my Variaudio 3 background back to a lighter color like 9.5 but cannot find which setting in the color preferences changes this. Where can I change it to look like yours? Thanks!
Not at my machine, but if I recall correctly, I adjusted the ‘Editor Background’ category under Custom Colours to give me that light hue. Wasn’t tricky or difficult as I remember… Good luck.!
Shameless bump of all these suggestions/requests. A gentle reminder:-
Zoom improvements. The Zoom Tool needs to have vertical zoom functionality, as well as horizontal - ‘free zooming’ as you mouse-drag. Would really, really help navigation and general ‘inside-the-window’ workflow.
Visual indication of background waveform when making a volume (amplitude) change - you allow showing time-warping of the waveform; we need to see amplitude change too.! Please.
Better distinction of the background waveform - thin outline or contrast improvement, whatever…
Double-click in empty space to re-position the playhead and start playback - check Melodyne behaviour. Its ace and super fast for the workflow.
Can the ‘Pitch Snap mode’ default, be set globally.?
Future, future request - what about displaying an entirely separate reference audio track (of our choosing) in a new window along the top/inside the main VA window…? I often don’t have any MIDI stuff in my projects (live sound/whole show multitrack audio). And besides, VA is not just for vocals…
in addition to all the very useful enhancements suggested here in this thread, I’d wish so see the following:
let me please create a preset for VariAudio 3 settings, so I do not have to make the same choices over and over again, like: zoom (a fixed zoom level, no matter how long the audio is), color mode, pitch snap mode, algorithm, smart controls, …
And please visualize the movement of the formant (like Melodyne) and show a little indicator (in dB), when a “blop” is changed in volume (only there, were is was changed), for future reference…
And finally: Would’t it be nice, if VariAudio 3 suggests the best algorithm for the audio itself (optional)
Suspend Auto-Scroll when Editing - should include when a segment is selected/highlighted.
So, you’re reviewing/auditioning a small section you’re working on; a segment of interest is highlighted. Currently the viewport will scroll away, as the playhead nears the right-hand side of the Sample Editor window. Not nice. If I’m just checking (trial and error) my adjustments, I want the highlighted segment to stay in view (until I click in some blank area to release its status/focus).
Please look at Melodyne’s workflow to see how useful/friendly/helpful this can be.!
Using a Rubber-band doesn’t scroll viewport (vertically) - click-dragging the mouse ‘out of bounds’ top or bottom of the Sample Editor window, won’t scroll the display. (Beyond left or right edges of the window, the display scrolls as expected).
Lots of people on large size/hi-DPI resolution screens probably won’t ever see this as an issue. But I’m on a 22" LCD at 1920x1080 and even with the Sample Editor in its own separate large-ish window, its a problem; laptop users will suffer most. Besides, this should just work.
Display full ‘Current Pitch’ info label in the segments - as zoom allows, only the note/pitch label (E2, F#2, etc.,) will be displayed inside a selected segment. There’s room to include the +/- % (percentage) value, as shown in the Info Line readout.
Would save all the ‘eyeball tennis’ you play, bouncing up and down to the Info Line and to where you are actually working…
Include a new slider to adjust background dynamic waveform contrast - a simple slider control would do, placed at the bottom of the window, next to horizontal zoom (see Request Idea 3 above). Would aid ‘visibility’ depending on personal choice of Editor Background colour.
This one from @BLOODMOON is super important… Please don’t forget.! :-
After working (VA) quite a bit this weekend, if there’s only time/resource for ONE more big improvement (maybe at v10.5 …?), please let it be this this one…
Its really lacking in the results (compared to how Melodyne copes).
can you make the background waveform more ‘visible’ when using lighter colour schemes…? See attached…
