What keyboard for note input?

I’m looking for a new midi controller for note input for Dorico. What do you use?

Hi @jk3horn, I use and love Korg microKEY keyboards (I use the non Air models). They come with different number of keys (25, 37, 49 and 61). Even if the keys are small, the feeling is really good and constant for the full length of the key. They have a very comfortable octave switch system, pitch bend and mood wheel (as joystick in the small 25 key model). Highly recommended, if you search something that doesn’t occupy much place on your desk, and is very reliable. You find those on Thomann for example:

Thanks Christian. I’ll check it out.

One thing to take into account: It’s irritating to keep having to switch octaves. 61 keys (5 octaves) isn’t enough for inputting harpsichord music let alone piano music without switching octaves.

If you have room and you can find a keyboard with a bigger range, it’s worth considering.

I think a lot depends on whether or not you need the velocity sensitivity. I’ve met some that have their dynamics entered according to how hard they hit the key.

I don’t even know if Dorico does that but I’m assuming it does.

Thanks for the advice.

Being principally a pianist, I use a Studiologic 88-key keyboard.
I couldn’t really afford the very high-end models with the weighted wooden keys, but this plays very well.

I think it depends on your keyboard skills, your available space and how you want to input notes.

My preferred MIDI keyboard is a Alesis Qmini (32 key). Virtually no desktop footprint and tiny keys! But I don’t input chords or do “real time” input. Most of my input is QWERTY.

I vote for Korg as well! My freinds love their 49- or 61-key microKEY keyboards, and I have a NanoKEY2 controller for quick edits. Also, I’ve noticed that not many people are aware that digital pianos can be used for music notation. I sometimes use my Yamaha YDP-143 for that. :slight_smile:

I have a fully weighted 88-key Studiologic as well as one of those cheap 25-key Akai thingies, representing pretty much the ends of both the price and portability spectra. And I can recommend both for the specific niche they fill. Anything in between will do the job too, it really depends on your further requirements.

I have to go the other way than many folks. For what I do, the M-AUDIO Keystation Mini 32 works just fine. As an added benefit, it fits in my backpack or rollaboard suitcase.

Look at the X-Key models (in 25 and 37-key models) if you prefer full-size keys and minimum depth facilitated by the small number of buttons, etc., most of which are unnecessary for inputting music. The height is also minimal and this allows for easy access to an alphanumeric keyboard if both are on the same level.

Novation Launchkey Mk IV. I have the 49- key version, and it fits easily on my desk in front of my computer keyboard. They do make a 61-key version, but not shown on their Launchkey page. Instead, they’ve filled out the line with an 88, a 25, 37, a 25 mini, and a 37 mini. The 37, 49, 61, and 88 all have full-size keys, and the largest three have modwheels and semi-weighted keys with aftertouch. I think they all have pads and endless encoders.

They’re all a great value for the price, with the 61 going for as little as $329 new. You can get the 37 for as little as $159 new.

Selecting a keyboard is very much a personal taste question. In my mind some things to take into account: narrow or standard with keys (if you are used to playing keyboards, maybe standard width? ) , weighted keys or organ type (if you are used to playing piano then maybe weighted might be the typical choice ) , velocity sensitive or not ( if you are not a piano player maybe not velocity sensitive), number of keys (more are better but takes more place).

My choice has been standard width, velocity turned off. I need at least 3 octaves but more is better. Brand or type makes no difference for me.

If all you need is to get notes onto staves, then a basic 2-octave controller is probably cheap enough to try with and not worry too much about chucking it out if it isn’t satisfactory.

I do have a 49 key version controller with normal key width. It is placed to the right of my work space. In a way that I can comfortably reach the first two octaves of that keyboard. I play with the right hand, whilst preselecting rhythms on the computer keyboard with the left hand. This means I sometimes do the gymnastics in stretching further out to the right, but quite often just use the octave keys.
Meaning, theoretically a smaller keyboard would be sufficient.