Additional Music Fonts

I get what you are saying. Really it depends on the font. There are many text fonts that are very similar to eachother. Even Arial and Helvetica, two of the most common text fonts, are very similar. As far as music fonts go, there are less options than text fonts, so I would agree with you for the most part they are similar. But just like text fonts, there are some very different fonts like this one BopMusic - SMuFL - Notation Central

1 Like

I’m sorry, I wasn’t clear. I know there are options and of course, you don’t use just one font for type. But as said above, there is a huge difference between Serif and Sans Serif fonts, let alone all other varieties. Whereas music fonts are much more nuanced.

My curiosity was more about how often you actually use a different typeface from the default. Did you find one that became your personal house style, or stick with Default and change other layout options.

Perhaps a silly inquiry. But I am curious.

In Finale, my default was a hodgepodge of a whole bunch of music fonts, mostly Maestro Wide and Engraver, but a few other fonts like Sonata thrown in as articulations, etc. In Dorico, I’ve mostly stuck to Bravura and have been content with some fairly obscure text typefaces for customization. I suppose I should probably revisit some of the other various font options for common glyphs myself.

1 Like

I always uses my own font with Dorico … because I’m not too fond with the default font, but honestly the default font it better than opus ,

P.S : I don;t know why I could not upload any file here …

I like to pick the font according to what feels good in relation to the material I’m working on. It somehow can even change how I feel about the music, and I believe the musicians can percieve this too (but perhaps subconsciously)

1 Like

@odhot are you talking about a text font or a music font? And what is ‘opus’ that you refer to? I have not heard of that.

I think Opus is the name of the font family supplied with Sibelius.

Well, having put together Sebastian, I use it exclusively, because it is exactly what I want! (within the confines of available talent and skill…)

I’d agree with Dan that music font choices are a bit more subtle than text font choices: the differences tend to be much more slight. I have a few criteria: quaver down-stem flags should be bulging, rather than the quill-like flick of Bravura/Maestro, and not quite touching the notehead; and G clefs shouldn’t lean one way or the other. I’m quite fussy about rectangular breves, and the ‘crossed 6’ bass figure.

We’re making a page of visual information. Of course the window dressing is crucial! Music engraving has as much to do with graphic design as it does with music.

There’s a balance between tradition and individuality. You want your page to be familiar, but not generic.

As nice as Bravura and New Century Schoolbook/Academico are (and better than many preceding music fonts coupled with Times), you might not want your page to look like everyone else’s page. Comparing with text fonts, Times New Roman (and Helvetica/Arial) are often seen as ‘the absence of a style decision’ (and there’s even a page saying the same about Minion Pro). That’s a bit harsh: you can still create personality and individuality with ‘default’ fonts, though it’s perhaps more difficult. There’s an argument that using a different font is a pejoratively ‘easy’ way of creating a unique design.

You can mix and match fonts, using Dorico’s Font Styles and Music Symbols editor. You can have Bass Figures from one font and dynamics from another; the trill symbol from a third; and so on.

Like wine with a meal, the text font(s) need to be paired with the music, and a page of Bravura will look very different surrounded by Plantin or Nepomuk or Minion or Avenir.

If you produce a wide range of different material – early music, contemporary, barbershop, jazz – then you may want to differentiate each style with a different music font. But we are overwhelmed with choice these days: printers and music engravers worked for centuries with only ‘one style’ of tools at their disposal.

2 Likes

You can find more SMuFL fonts here: List of SMuFL fonts?

1 Like

thanks @benwiggy - this is exactly what I was curious about. In my previous life as I graphic designer, we would often agonize over typeface subtleties and differences. When it comes to notation, I’ve both lost my eye* a bit for picking out the details, and noticing the slight changes a different typeface can add.

I have spent a lot of dollars on typefaces over the years, and so I am not against spending the money for good typeface design. I was more curious professional engraver’s attitudes and thoughts on this.

There’s a balance between tradition and individuality. You want your page to be familiar, but not generic.

This makes total sense, and a great way to phrase it. Thanks!

*To be honest, I have never really given notation that much thought until this past 6 months or so. I have taken notation so much for granted and never truly studied it as a separate piece of art.

1 Like

For a time, I used November, but I found myself continually going back to Bravura. I find I prefer to focus on text fonts for a unique look. I did make some changes to things like line thickness, and sometimes I change out the treble clef.

I’m working with a client on a major hymnal project that we anticipate being pretty broadly used. For the lyrics, they’re using a very expensive and uncommon text font. And for the music font… we’re using Bravura. :sunglasses:

I do like Sebastian. And @LSalgueiro has a beautiful font called Iris, but I haven’t had occasion to use it yet.

3 Likes

These threads are from 2015, but a bunch of us were discussing the fine details of a bunch of music glyphs over on the Notatio forum, with side-by-side examples. I didn’t re-read all of it to see if my opinions have changed over the years, but you might find the discussion and variety of fonts interesting.

Thread on clef design
Thread on rest design

Elbsound Studio has a pretty cool music font comparison tool with lots of music fonts. Unfortunately the majority of them are not SMuFL-compliant, but you can at least see how some of them look when used on a few different musical examples.

1 Like

Also, even though many fonts are not SMuFL-compliant, you can pretty easily pull glyphs from them and use them in Dorico via with Music Symbols editor.

2 Likes

I’ve agonized over fonts as well. (I think many of us here have.) Going for absolute clarity and a traditional look, I’ve landed on TenOldStyle and IowanOldStyle as my fonts of choice.

For music fonts, I love the dorico default. It’s bold and traditional. Other fonts often look very anemic to my eye, whereas bravura has a very timeless/classic look without being too weighty or kludgy. It’s just right. (You can always tell a finale default score because it’s so “wispy”. )

To my delight, I’m starting to find some Dorico scores floating around in the wild now on places like cpdl, although they are certainly less common.

1 Like

I uses my own music font and of course mix with Nepomuk (the best expression font for me)
https://imgur.com/SMXfdS5

How often do we use music fonts other than Bravura? That seems like a valid question. I have 10 SMuFL-compliant fonts installed, which I all like, but I haven’t used any of them yet. It’s good to have them (probably the hunter-collector-syndrome), in case one day a score should look like one of Henle or Peters. But for everyday use Bravura is just fine.

It has already been mentioned that the differences among the fonts touch the subconscious rather than the recognizable. The same applies to text fonts, but there the differences are much more obvious. There are worlds between serifs and sans serifs, Slab or Display fonts. My current sans serif favorite is Linotype Syntax. The serifs are the familiar ones: Adobe Minion Pro, Adobe Garamond. I still think Times New Roman is of classic beauty, despite being so well known. Linotype Walbaum is a bit special, but very appealing. I thing it’s Schott’s corporate typeface.

1 Like

I find Sebastian to be my most used font after Bravura, especially when I need to have more vertical density (I find it behaves really well with a note spacing between 3 and 3.5 while Bravura shines between 3.5 and 4)
That is just my taste, though. YMMV :wink:
And for a really different looks, I use November 2.
I also use some NorFonts ones (the regular ones, not the hand-written style ones).

2 Likes

My son had a swim meet yesterday, and if any of you have kids that swim, you’ll understand that a championship-level meet is basically sitting around for 5 hours to watch your kid swim for 5 minutes. It’s noisy and loud and not conducive to work, so I did a thing …

Here’s a little music font comparison with 8 SMuFL fonts. The fonts are in order from left to right, Bravura, Finale Engraver, Finale Legacy, Finale Maestro, Leipzig, Leland, November2, and Sebastian. All are free to download except for November which must be purchased. As most of these are Playing Techniques, they have all been manually positioned. The positioning may not be 100% accurate so don’t necessarily make judgements based on the positioning.

Treble clefs

Bass clefs

Alto clefs

Time sigs

Sharps (remember positioning may not quite be correct)

Flats

Noteheads

Articulations, fingerings, dynamics, etc (some fonts do not contain SMuFL fingerings)

Here’s the file if anyone wants to play around with it, zoom in to compare glyphs, or add additional fonts to compare. It’s possible there are errors too so if you find any, let me know.

MusicFontComparision.dorico (979.6 KB)

13 Likes

@FredGUnn Can I just say I hope your son has many more swim meets ahead of him

5 Likes

Ha, yeah he does! He’s swimming an ocean mile race on Sunday (I’d probably drown if I attempted that) but I don’t think I’m bringing my laptop to the beach. Maybe next meet …

2 Likes