As I continue Writing for Christmas

I have always liked the tune ABERYSTWYTH (how do they get these names?!). I think it works much better for ‘Watchman, Tell Us of the Night’ than ‘Jesus Lover of My Soul’, although since this is an instrumental work, without knowing the title it makes little difference. I got the idea of weary travelers approaching their city and calling out to the guard on the watchtower. I used a Percussion ostinato and integrated touches of percussion color in various ways as it progresses. I do enjoy prepping music for the Christmas season :slightly_smiling_face:



Just for giggles (and to see if my 32g of Ram could handle it) here it is using John’s BBC Core pt:

BTW, to avoid any copyright issues for using an image as a score cover, I asked Opera Browser’s AI to create one. Quite appropriate, I think.

From a search engine (and true): The hymn tune Aberystwyth is named after the coastal town in Wales where the composer, Joseph Parry, was living and working when he wrote it. It follows the common tradition of naming a new hymn tune after the location of its creation or the composer’s residence. Nice arrangement.

Thank you. And, it’s nice to know the source of the title.

It’s far too early to be using, or even thinking about the C-word. Not til the Summer holidays are over, at the absolute earliest!!! :laughing:

Tell this to those who are already planning their winter concert. :rofl:

Im always surprised by how late in the year some publishers will send out their newsletters promoting christmas music. Sorry, guys, my planning has been done months ago and we are already rehearsing…

It’s already Christmastime at some retailers​:pleading_face:

I got an email today from Lowe’s (big box hardware retailer in the USA) advertising Christmas decorations! :scream::santa_claus:t3::christmas_tree:

I prefer my holidays in proper order-and time.

I like your arrangements! I thought I might chime in a bit on AI generated images. Sometimes AI “borrows” others’ work so I would always ask the AI to make a completely unique image that no one (and no AI) has ever made. We lack a lot of guardrails for AI usage and results at the moment which is a little scary for any of us who hold intellectual property of any type that is “out there.” It may freak out the AI entity, though… :slight_smile:

Thanks! And, that is good advice. I will take it to heart; I hadn’t really considered the possibility of AI ‘borrowing’ from others’ work.

How else does it ‘learn’ anything? (that’s the rip off)

It would be interesting to see how an AI would evolve if it went through the same education and training that we have through childhood, young adulthood and later throughout life. I’m sure it could “learn” all of this quite quickly (minutes or hours compared to years or decades).

No, it wouldn’t. AI doesn’t work that way. (I also think these things are by definition unable to create art, but that would take us into a discussion on what art is so I won’t elaborate.)

I’ll instead suggest to pay an actual artist for the cover art. It’s probably much less expensive than you think.

And if your score is for private use only and not to be distributed, I’d argue that simply using someone’s art without permission is ethically much better than using AI.

You do realise that “AI” isn’t sentient (or intelligent), right? Adding that to your prompt is no guarantee against plagiarism.

Nor does it have any ethical bias, morality, or compunction about lying!

Oh, I know that. It’s just a little humor that didn’t come across that way.

Maybe lighten up a bit…I was being facetious. By the way, AI can certainly generate images (whether you decide it’s art or not is your business). An example: https://leonardo.ai/. And, AI can be trained to “look” at things like we humans do through human coaching and the like (Training AI to see more like humans | NSF - U.S. National Science Foundation).

Humour never works predictably across linguistic and cultural divides, so is best avoided altogether.

Not on the topic of AI, I won’t. (Yes, I know about the image generators and I wish nobody would use them. Ever.) I will however try to not go on and on about it in this forum.