Auto-Return Positioning Seriously Needs Rethinking

When editing MIDI velocity or CC data in the MIDI editor or automation data in the project track area, there’s a maddening behavior that is deeply counterproductive. It has to do with the use of auto-return in conjunction with auto-scroll.

Suppose you are editing measures 16 thru 21 of a project. You might set your view up such that the first measure displayed is 15, the last 22, and you’d set the cursor at the start of 16. Do your edits and press play to hear the results. Since this process is likely to be iterative, you’d want auto-return to be enabled. Auto-return returns the cursor to the start of measure 16 after the quick audition, and you’re efficiently set up for the next iteration.

Now, this is all straight-forward as long as you don’t have auto-scroll enabled. If auto-scroll is on and the playback goes beyond the end of measure 22, scrolling does indeed occur. When you stop playback, we return to a view where the cursor is at the start of measure 16, but there’s a major problem. The view is now such that the first displayed measure is 9 and the last is 16. So most of the measures you want to work on (17 thru 21) are now off screen. This cannot possibly be useful behavior in any context.

It turns out there’s a clunky word-around. If you now press play, playback starts, but first the view is readjusted to be what you set up in the first place: measures 15 thru 22 displayed. Stop playback before scrolling kicks in and you’re back to where you need to be. In other words, press the space bar twice and you don’t have to mess with adjusting your start positioning. But you shouldn’t have to contend with this kind of needless fiddling.

This is so frustrating that I’m forced to keep auto-scroll disabled when doing this kind of editing. That’s a shame because auto-scroll really is an extremely helpful feature. Please, please fix this.

Agreed. And it should be simple, when “flipping the screen” to return to position, ensure the playhead is to the left of the screen.
With say about 10% space on the left, 90% on the right.

I’d rather have this type of issue fixed than have Studio Delay or Shimmer.

There are several issues with the editor positioning/zoom on opening… Is it relative to the cursor position? Does it have anything to do with the project window scaling? I’m trying to understand if there is any logic to it so I can work it to my advantage.

It really is a pain. On more than one occasion I’ve tried to think of a reasonable rationale for why this works the way it does, but I keep drawing blanks.

Agreed.

I hope Steinberg friends see this :
No reverb or delay is going to get new customers, we are spoilt for free ones ! No matter how charming of a smug smile Dom Sigalas squeezes, new plugins don’t work any more.
Smooth workflow enhancements keep existing paying customers buying the upgrades though. Think details through ! Make things smooth and listen to all the feedback. Thanks Steinberg.

I just installed Cubase 14 and was disappointed (but not surprised) that this problem is still present. It also manifests when using navigation to markers. In the screen shots below we have a project with multiple markers. At (1) we are at marker 1, measure 1. At (2) we have have moved to marker 2, measure 31 using the num-2 key shortcut. At (3) we have moved to marker 3, measure 65 using num-3. Finally at (4) we have moved back to marker 2 using num-2.

But look at the final disposition. We do see measure 31, but it’s slammed up against the right side of the editing field. Who can this behavior be helping? I challenge anyone at Steinberg to provide an explanation as to why this behavior is beneficial to anyone.

Steinberg, please fix this. It is beyond frustrating! This for me is the most annoying thing in all of Cubase. There’s really no excuse IMO.

Entirely agreed, exact same frustration here, daily.
It’s part of these “small details” that mean much more than say adding yet another reverb or compressor.

We love you Steinberg, please fix this one for us ! :smiley:

OK, I just installed Cubase 15 and my expected disappointment was delivered. There is no change in the auto-return positioning after scrolling off the initial display has happened. That means that, for me at least, using auto-scroll and return-on-stop at the same time is a no-go. Auto-positioning the play-head near the right border of the project window or the key-editor window or the tempo-editor window is a total workflow assassin. So, it looks like it’s another year without having auto-scroll available. Surely I cannot be the only user who finds auto-scroll with return-on-stop a useful feature combination.

Even more maddening is that I have a work-around that almost delivers. The command sequence toggle-auto-scroll/start-stop/ toggle-auto-scroll to do a stop can be used instead of just start-stop and the resultant screen position is absolutely perfect. It does no harm when as a start substitute as well. It works just fine if I execute the command sequence using A/space/A from the computer keyboard (with A being the hotkey for toggle-auto-scroll on my system). So, I made a macro and assigned a trigger key to that. If I execute that macro with Run Macro in the key commands editor window, it works just fine. If I run it with its assigned hot key, there’s some timing issue: on stop, the screen repositions as desired but playback immediately recommences.

I tried various tricks. I put a sequence of a dozen send-all-notes-off commands in various places to see if I could introduce a delay that would fix things. No joy. I introduced a nested macro configuration to see if that would duplicate the behavior when using the Run Macro command. No joy. I wish I knew why Run Macro was the magic kiss of success. So near, yet so far.

It would be ever so nice if Steinberg would acknowledge that this issue is a legitimate problem and fix it. They’ve already got working code somewhere: whatever routine gets called when auto-scroll is enabled clearly does the job just fine!

Solution! Welcome back to my workflow, auto-scroll!

To those following this thread, the almost-solution in the post immediately above this one came close but the macro did not work when run with a hot key. Yesterday I came up with something almost as good which works perfectly. When using auto-scroll and return-to-start-position-on-stop, my much preferred way of working in the project/key-editor/tempo-editor windows, upon stop the return happens and we are positioned with the play-head near the left margin, with the measures I’m working to the right of the play-head and exposed for immediate attention.

The “almost as good” is due to it being limited to separate start and stop keys, not a toggle like you currently get with the space key. You only need one additional macro to take advantage of this approach – you can still use the space key (which runs the start/stop command) for starting playback. But I opted for an additional new macro and hotkey that does just a start. I assigned the new stop and start macros to “,” and “.” respectively; those symbols sharing the key surface with “<” and “>”, making the assignments easy to remember.

While at it, I decided another command to do a stop with no return would come in handy now that I can finally work in auto-scroll mode. This got assigned to “/, to the immediate right of “<” and “>”. The three new macros are shown in the image.

This scroll behaviour issue is exactly the type of issues I need resolved to purchase the upgrade to Cubase. There is no single addition that can make me want to spend money more than those behaviour fixes. @Matthias_Quellmann Thanks Matthias to bump this up if you have time :wink: