I’m trying to wrap my head around this feature and its becoming tedious because the software isn’t very forgiving when I screw up the placement of a Condensing Change. Has anyone figured out a way to:
Move a Condensing Change while in Engrave mode or
Create a Condensing Change while in Write mode or
If a Condensing Change is desired mid-measure and all the staves are already condensed, how do you select the mid-measure point without having to turn off condensing, select the point and turning condensing back on?
I find myself having to go back and forth between modes and turning the feature on and off constantly. I do understand that there is a learning curve, but if correcting oneself could be made a little easier, consider this a feature request.
Thank you. Yes, I’ve watched this and other videos on Condensing. The fact that the Dorico folks titled their video “Demystifying Condensing” suggests that they know that using this feature is confusing/mystifying for users.
I believe I know how the feature works. It’s just hard for my brain to take in every little contrapuntal moment in a large score to get it right the first time - those dozens of times where I didn’t consider this or that in some voice somewhere in the score (vertically or horizontally) that causes me to have to move Condensing Changes left or right or add them mid-measure.
I suppose I’m asking if there is a faster way to edit the position Condensing Changes while I’m in the process of Engraving. Not placing them in the wrong place is the first place is ideal…but I’m only human.
I suspect this had more to do with the linguistic fun to be had by drawing a parallel between “mist” and “condensation” than intending to cast a judgement about the complexity of using the feature!
I’d say it comes up pretty regularly. But because it is such a complicated subject, almost every issue that gets brought up requires actually going into the project file and figuring out what’s the matter, so you won’t find much ‘general wisdom’ in those threads.
Yes, more study is always good. I’m able to quickly figure out why something went awry. The issue is keeping all the notes of a group of instruments for the last phrase in my head such that I can predict all the possible outcomes. The music (at least the stuff I’m working with now) is so contrapuntal in places that it’s not always easy to see the thing 8 bars/2 pages back or 2 staves down that is affecting or will be affected by a Condensing Change. Also, Many of the global setting work for most instrument alot of the time but need to be overridden for different groups of instruments at various difference times, so I’m stuck playing whack a mole! It’s usually after I’ve input the C-Change when I see a new problem and then hunt for the hidden cause…and then re-edit C-Change.
Here’s hoping there will be faster methods in the Condensing Change re-editing process. Two simple to say suggestions (I don’t know how simple they are to implement) would be to allow dragging/nudging/copy n’ pasting of C-Changes in Engraver Mode and/or allow C-Change creation in Write mode. The former seems like the more logical solution.
Of course it is, when one first encounters it. Dorico was the first notation program to introduce condensing, so it would naturally be initially unfamiliar–or mystifying. (Since no other program had the feature, I guess it couldn’t be called “unintuitive” to those trapped in the Finale or Sibelius mindset of the time.)