Agreed with most of what you wrote except this point. This is exactly why many people have trouble: they think it’s not relevant today. And yes, for some people they get a magic combination and it works out fine for them, which it did for you in this case, but not for everyone. It’s still very relevant today, and it rolls in phases in the industry… we just went through a very tough time IMO, with a huge number of issues on all platforms, although it is stabilizing somewhat in 2024/2025.
Again, many people are not so lucky. Windows can be frustrating for many DAW users, depending on many factors, especially CPU generation-related issues in recent years, etc… Apple users are not immune either! It’s not nearly the plug and play situation you imply. You rolled the dice and the timing was right for your CPU/chipset/OS combination, and/or you built/bought a lucky system.
Your system is from late 2019, so I can only assume you built perhaps an Intel 9900K (late 2018 release) or Ryzen 3700X (mid-late 2019 release) - or something similar. If so, those two were both very stable machines out of the box (I still have both of those in the studio, they both work great!), and same situation with that generation in general, depending on chipset. My 9900K machine needed very few tweaks, it’s true, probably the most stable DAW I’ve ever had, fewest issues. But simply take a look at the mess when Intel P/E cores were introduced in 2021, it took a while to resolve some of that, not to mention the 13th/14th gen issues with over-voltage (which were eventually resolved), not to mention thread scheduling differences between Win 10 and Win 11 now, etc… By late 2021 (12th gen Intel) things were actually in VERY bad shape IMO. Lots of issues, so many that Steinberg even said not to get a 12th gen until they could work things out (which they eventually addressed fairly well IMO).
I could give some examples from various issues with AMD Ryzen machines, USB issues, Thunderbolt issues, Apple Silicon issues, more P/E issues, various OS issues on both platforms, and so forth. Quick example, I just recently had issues resolved with iLok and my new AMD 9950x. What a mess that was. but it’s now resolved (thank goodness) and works great. But what a mess. There were workarounds, that only partially worked. It was so idiotic and frustrating. I’ve got personal examples from recent Intel gen, Apple Silicon, etc…
Point is, one could easily argue that things got substantially worse after your 2019 build, where my advice became very relevant again. In your case, looks like you timed it and lucked out. I’ve got many machines that had issues, almost all platforms (including Linux, but not yet Windows on ARM). My 2019 builds were among the most reliable and easy to set up, like yours.
Anyway, not to make a big deal about it, again, I agree with much of what you say, and I enjoy your posts in general, I’m just saying it’s not so cut and dried, and the advice is still relevant. And we didn’t even touch on portable machines, which is another mess. I have laptops from 6 years ago that work better as DAWs than laptops from 2 years ago. Go figure.
I think anyone having troubles today should start with the general premise that their computers should be treated as dedicated DAWs to get the most out of them, and that idea gets you about 95% of the way there. If someone wants to roll the dice (and might get lucky), or start adding other things to their DAW like gaming, streaming, etc., be prepared to introduce potential issues to the situation. Sometimes it works out fine, then great. It’s possible that the impact will be very minor, and so more power to folks who do that. But when someone STARTS with that premise, I predict many frustrations for them. All it takes is one misbehaving driver, or one OS patch, one conflicting app, one errant plugin, one sub-optimal OS setting, one dumb little thing, from breaking something or introducing instability. My view is, reduce those potential issues as much as possible, and start there as the basis. Then build up from there if you want to.
Anyway, cheers, this is just my opinion, YMMV, and again, I enjoy your posts - much respect as usual!