I taught a class in how to use Dorico at a handbell event last summer and will do so again next summer. One topic I had to address is that Finale can automatically create a bells used chart and Dorico can’t.
So I have a couple questions that are a part of this overall question: Does Dorico announce a release schedule? Does the schedule announce what major components will be in a release?
The last time I discussed a bells used chart on this forum I think it was left as: It’s a known need and is on our list of things to do. Will I be able to give my summer 2027 class an idea of when Dorico will be able to generate a bells used chart?
For last summer’s class I created class notes, essentially a manual covering everything a handbell composer needs to know about using Dorico. At the time I created those notes based on Dorico 5, though Dorico 6 had already been released, because that was what I was using (I’m still using it) and that’s the version most Finale refugees had installed, even if they hadn’t started using Dorico. Will Dorico 7 be released before next July and should I plan to update the images in my class notes?
Thank you. Perhaps a follow-up question: Can someone confirm that creating a bells used chart is a known need for handbell composers and will likely be included in Dorico … eventually?
The last time I discussed the bells used chart I proposed that I write a plugin as had been done for Finale. I was told that isn’t possible because the Dorico script does not provide a way to interrogate the project to find out what pitches it contains. Is that considered a known need?
The process is not automatic, but by selecting the entire Handbell part and then viewing the Keyboard diagram in the lower panel, one can see by the blue dots the notes used. That’s a start.
Thank you. I’m well aware of that technique and mentioned it in my classes. However, the keyboard doesn’t distinguish between F-sharp and G-flat, which might be played by different people, and actually creating the chart still takes some effort.
I’m also familiar with using Music XML to transfer the score to Finale and using its plugin to generate the chart.
I still eagerly anticipate the time that Dorico will generate the chart for me.
Intriguing… is the sound different? Are some bells marked F#, others Gb? What are the circumstances different people play different ‘spellings’ of (I presume) the same pitch? Is a set of bells for a player set up strictly diatonic in a fixed key, which may differ between players?
Sorry for my curiosity, I may be wasting everybody’s time here. TBH, it’s quite unlikely that I’ll ever write for handbells at all, so don’t bother if you have better things to do. Cheers!
One bell is marked with both F# and Gb. In standard bell assignments one person would be assigned to ring two adjacent diatonic notes, such as E and F, their neighbor would be assigned G and A. An F# would usually be played by the EF ringer, the Gb by the GA ringer.
The ringers use the bells used chart to remind themselves what bells they need to have in front of them before the music starts. That includes what bells they may have to share with a neighbor and to position the bell accordingly.
Have you had a look at the new Maestro Score program? It was officially released a few weeks ago with the basics working, but is still being developed, adding more features (including scripting to come).
I have been sending old Finale files which did not import correctly and subsequent updates fixed them.
It will import Finale files and if you had details of your Finale plugin, they might be able to help you get it working. There is a “From Finale” page on their website you might be interested in.
You will find Dorico’s output looks much more elegant compared to Maestro, but you might find you can quickly export xml to Dorico if you need to print to finalize, use Maestro (since you all came from Finale?) as the input process and your bells used chart.
Just a suggestion
(no affiliation with Maestro, but I’m interested in its progress.)
What I like about Dorico is a great deal more than its inability to automatically generate a bells used chart. These days I’m not importing much from Finale, I’m writing new stuff. Thanks for the idea, but I’ll stick to Dorico.