Dorico 6.2.40 crashing a lot

As much as I was looking forward to this update, it is, sadly, just not ready for prime time. Dorico has crashed five times in the last hour (even after reboot) and that hasn’t happened to me in almost a year. I’m also getting stuck notes on almost every playback–especially with scrub–and that hasn’t happened in almost as long.

While it’s probably a step forward for a lot of us, it’s a hard step back for my workflow.

I’ll hang with it for now, as I’m confident a fix will be out the door soon…

On a happier note, I was able to, for the first time, import a musicxml files with all my percussion parts intact and in the right places!

I guess it would help the development team if you could provide more details about your system. Which OS, which version.
A Diagnostic Report after the crash maybe will help too

That’s all in my profile, and has been since day 1.

Please do Help > Create Diagnostic Report and attach the resulting zip file here, so I can take a look at your crash logs and see what’s going on.

Oh, and I know about the problem with scrub playback – that will only be happening with NotePerformer. Sorry for the inconvenience. If that’s really troublesome, please try switching to the Auto playback template for the time being.

It happens other times, but mostly when I scrub over a gliss. Again, this hasn’t happened in ages until now.

Diagnostic file is over 8MB. Any way to reduce that?

Here’s a link, if that works…

Dorico Diagnostics.zip

Something else I just noticed. In write mode, when I’m in a percussion kit staff, cycling through each instrument now takes up to a full second. That has always been instantaneous for me.

You can get rid of the stuck notes in scrub playback by starting regular playback, which sends a blanket NoteOff command. Or by scrubbing more slowly across the same passage, in either direction.

Yeah. I’ve been doing that a lot today.

Another oddity… after a crash (usually during playback) when I open the recovery file, it’s already playing. I have to press play a couple of times to get it to stop.

Unfortunately there are no crash logs in your diagnostic zip file, Clancy. Is Dorico in fact hanging rather than crashing, such that you need to force quit it?

Well, it completely disappears and I have to restart it. Wouldn’t it just reappear if it was still running? What I get is the hub and a message to recover a file.

Not sure why it isn’t making a crash log. But it’s pretty spectacular when it goes. No elegant, but useless info about “encountering a problem” I so often see with Windows programs–just… vanished.

Now… I had imported my percussion parts via mxml, and it has been sitting there as a second flow this whole time. Since I’ve deleted that flow, I haven’t noticed any more issues. But that could be because I’m saving after every edit, and it just knows and is waiting. :slight_smile:

If there’s a particular project that appears to be the cause of the instability, that’s what we need. If you can remember what actions seemed to be causing Dorico to vanish in a puff of smoke, then please provide me with the project you were working on (or the MusicXML file) and describe the steps you were taking that caused Dorico to abort.

Yeah… that should have been one of the first things I did here.

Just Add Sleigh Bells.dorico (1.5 MB)

I had already removed the imported flow, so I put it back for this in case that was causing the problem. Also, this should be played with NotePerformer to keep everything the same.

Prior to the new version, scrub was working. I do use NP. I’m going to reinstall previous version.

Thanks for attaching the project, Clancy. Is there anything in particular you can remember doing that seemed to bring about the crash?

It always seemed to happen right after an edit then pressing play. I don’t think it mattered what part I was editing. If it crashes for you in that moment, be sure to reload the autosave… it will open already playing where you left off.

Were you editing anything specific, e.g. any particular instrument or part?

Not that I recall. I think it happened first on the percussion parts, but I know it happened on others. The first three or four times, I had to rewrite a bit. Got me between autosaves and ctrl-S bashing.

Hello,

I’m having a similar issue, I feel this is probably related so I post it on this thread. Let me know if I should start a new thread instead.

It appeared with update 6.2.40. Dorico crashed at least five times in the first hour after the update. This seem to be happening only when the playback template is NotePerformer. On my side, Dorico 6 has also been very stable up until this last update.

When I hit playback (P) right after selecting a item (note or other), Dorico crashes instantly. I did not use the scrub playback, just the classic one. The VSTAudio engine must then be manually closed in the task manager (I’m on Windows) before starting Dorico again.

Here is a link to the diagnostic archive :

Dorico Diagnostics

And I automatically sent the crashdumps to the Dorico team when restarting the software.

Thanks for investigating the issue.

So, since I removed the mxml import flow from the file, it’s been stable as far as I can tell. However, this morning when I opened Dorico, I get this:

The hub appears, and I can open a file, but there is no sound with NotePerformer. I’ll try with another template to see if that changes anything. Not sure why I would just now be getting this message.