Envelope Shaper is very clicky

I love the idea of an Envelope Shaper build it with the Channel strip , but when ever I have tried to use it almost alway get clicking added to the signal .

this happen while I try to remove a little attack on a Piano or add attack for Percussion .

is anyone able to use this ???

What version are you using? I don’t get this on Cubase 12. Win 11

Latest C13 , Mac

Im gonna do sound audio examples . A ,B with a 3rd party Env shaper , maybe simpler

This is a simple Piano note repeated one clean one other wit Env Shaper set to -20db to try and give the piano a softer attack , you will hear a click as the start of every note. not sure if there’s a better way to share audio clips , but links below

I would really like to use the C13 built in , I love Channel Strip

Screenshot 2024-02-16 at 11.23.06

Screenshot 2024-02-16 at 11.54.29

Screenshot 2024-02-16 at 11.53.49

finally if you use a Long Release with Env Shaper its unusable
Screenshot 2024-02-16 at 11.58.57

2 Likes

OK after all that , I just tried the Plug-in Version and that is work as expected, no clicks .
I think I’m gonna report this as a bug this cannot be right

Screenshot 2024-02-16 at 12.01.49

1 Like

Can I ask if you’re using the plug-in version, or the built-in Channel strip version?

Plug in version. I don’t use the channel strip. I’m not able to check at the moment though

I can confirm that the Envelope Shaper in the Channel Strip causes clicks whereas the plugin version does not.

3 Likes

Thx man for confirming, I love CS in cubase I hope this gets fixed soon

Hello
I can confirm this.
Cubase 13.0.20, macOS Ventura 13.6.4

1 Like

Thanks for reporting!

Yes, thanks for reporting this, guys!

1 Like

its reported FingersX

1 Like

Are you using Mac and windows ?

Thx

I’m on Windows 10.

thx , I talking to support , this will help

and you running Cubase 11 ?

No, Cubase Pro 12. I do have 11 and 10.5 installed still.

ok thanks , do you know if all version click in channel strip ?

I only tested and confirmed on version 12.