Feature Request: Independent Time Signatures and Bar Durations for Individual Instruments
I would like to suggest an improvement to Dorico’s handling of independent time signatures and bar durations in individual instrument staves.
The situation:
Imagine a score in which the main ensemble is written in 4/4, but one instrument needs to display 12/8 while maintaining exactly the same bar duration and barline alignment as the other instruments.
This is a perfectly valid musical and notation requirement, particularly when different rhythmic interpretations or subdivisions are used simultaneously.
The current workaround:
It is possible to achieve this in Dorico by using a time signature such as 12/8,8, followed by additional local time signature adjustments and hidden tuplets (12:8).
Although this works, the process is unnecessarily complicated. It requires several operations, including hidden time signatures and hidden tuplets, to achieve what should be a relatively straightforward notation task.
My suggestion:
It would be very useful to have a dedicated option for independent time signatures with independently configurable bar durations.
For example:
Main staff: 4/4 (8 eighth notes).
Independent staff: 12/8 (also occupying the duration of 8 eighth notes).
Both staves would share exactly the same barlines.
The 12/8 notation would be displayed normally, without requiring hidden tuplets or additional hidden time signatures.
Ideally, this could be configured directly when entering the time signature, through a simple option such as “Match bar duration to another staff” or “Independent time signature with synchronized barlines.”
This would make Dorico considerably more flexible for scores involving polymetric notation, different rhythmic subdivisions, and independent instrumental notation.
Honestly, I don’t think so. It’s a “false good idea” as we French say. Just like all the features that were added for Finale refugees in late 2024 — the shortcut to put a bar in the previous or next system. The system you have now, with fake pick-up bars, local time signatures and hidden tuplet expose the real stuff happening under the hood (as would showing the signposts with breaks and their properties while moving bars from one system to another). The difference between the two is that the people producing sync’d polymetric notation know what they are doing, while those who move bars often do not know how it’s happening, and once they have done so and want to reproduce it to add another bar in that system, can run into problems, instead of moving the break signpost…
The system that exists right now is super robust and clean. It’s a little bit complex, but can be explained step by step, and requires basic mathematical knowledge. I’m afraid an apparently more user-friendly solution makes things more obscure, especially when you want to modify stuff after the fact.
Expose for Dorico only, but not the real rhythmic state.
I do think the idea submitted by @gilbertosalvagni isn’t a bad idea (in other words, being able to choose how to behave by selecting from a range of options), particularly when combining time signatures more complex than the 4/4 and 12/8 given as example. The aim would then be to clearly indicate to Dorico that the time signatures are different; telling it to use lots of tuplets or quartolets and false pick-up actually masks the true situation. I therefore think that, at present, Dorico simply doesn’t know how to handle this. We might be surprised to find in Dorico 8 or 9 that our friend wish has simply been granted, just as Dorico 6 introduced cut-away scores that had been requested for ages.
We mustn’t confuse habit with a rejection of progress.
This is absolutely true. What I did point out is how some of these “progresses” have caused more problems than solved them. I usually teach how to input breaks and modify the properties (which actually can do anything you need) instead of using those macro buttons, because in the end it’s way more robust and clear.
You talk about cutaway scores, this is a different matter. Something that was simply impossible has become very easy (and robust). If they can implement polymetric notation with those qualities (precise, easy and robust) I will buy it 100%.
My position is more a pragmatic one: I have experienced explaining the way it is now, and the learning person was not happy with the different steps at first, because it implies learning a workflow that seems complicated. Once it’s clear the workflow is not complicated, but complex (to a low degree), the person learning it accepts it because it’s clear how powerful it is, and how it can be modified or corrected. But again, if a beautiful implementation simplifies this workflow, I will happily use it, teach it and promote it if need be.
My first thought (although I realize it is an oversimplification) is that this is a lot of work for programmers so folks can do another implementation of Jesu, Joy of Man’s Desiring.
It strikes me this may not be entirely independent of the desire for “real” support for so-called “irrational” time signatures like 7/10, 5/12, etc. etc.
After all, that 4/4 vs 12/8 with same bar length could also be expressed as a 4/4 time signature against a 12/12 one.
More precisely, what’s being looked for here is a way to write a time signature that also comes with a persistent scaling of duration: 12/12 (for example) is the same as “12/8 with a 3:2 scale”. Supporting both modern and old music requires being able to write such time signatures either way but with the same layout and playback results.
For me, it really comes down to pulse. If the pulse is once per bar, I should be able to mix 3/4, 2/2, 2/4, 3/8, etc., as all can be demonstrated as one pulse per bar. With a two-pulse metric, you could mix 6/8, 2/4, 2/2, 5/8, etc. The more pulses per bar, the more freedom you should have in assigning meters to the entire ensemble or individual parts within the ensemble. And if I want to mix meters, I should be able to define the pulse for those bars, and when I assign time signatures, Dorico just gets it: i.e., “the dude wants one pulse per bar, so, yeah, I can make 2/4 and 3/4 work together.”