Figured bass - accidental won't disappear

Good evening! I’m having a problem with entering figured bass. I’ve tried to add the “!” and I tried to toggle off every possible option to not show accidentals for figured bass in the notation options. Yet still, Dorico keeps adding the sharp sign to my 5. The only solution would be to accept the natural sign for the 5 but that doesn’t make sense, as there is no sharp for this note anywhere nearby. Is there anything I can do? Thank you!

I suspect you need to turn on “Allow diminished intervals” in Note Input Options: