Hearing dry guitar along with wet

I’m playing an electric guitar through a Yamaha Audiogram into Cubase AI 5. I have Guitar Rig as an insert. Everything works pretty good, but I keep hearing the dry guitar input along with what comes out of Guitar Rig via Cubase. I’m monitoring with headphones plugged into the Audiogram.

I just got back into this after being away from it for several months. I don’t remember having this problem before.

Maybe I should post this in the Yamaha forums, but I thought I’d start here. Any suggestions?

Can you adjust the balance on the Audiogram between the input and the computer return??

Yes. I have it turned all the way to DAW-only.