Honest feedback - What a mess! SDA/SLM/SAM

Same here. I understand why some would use Java, it’s just not my personal cup of tea.

:grinning_face:

That reminds me of that Tantacrul video about Dorico whose first thing to talk about before he even gets into the software was how complicated the whole process of getting the software was and how two people he asked to record videos of that process with him gave up when they learned they had to create an account to download demo software. Some had issues with the registration process and going the whole “access code to licenser” process.

It’s all largely in the past and to have a single application to manage all applications, libraries and licenses would great, in which case it would be of benefit for new users to create an account, as that would mean Steinberg and/or Yamaha, could provide tutorials and so on to keep people interested, during the 60-day trial period.

To demo Bitwig and Live you need to open an account. It’s pretty common practice, especially for major software.

Thanks for chiming in !

Your historical explanation makes sense. Actually, I don’t mind the three different programs, each having their role but, IMO, what is essentially in need is some clear and step to step instructions explaining how, once purchased, a product should be installed (SDA), activated (SAM) and eventually set as much as possible in the desired location (SLM), this, for several situations such as a purchase after having already installed its trial version or for different upgrades situations (‘Elements/Artist’ → ‘Pro’…) or context (Education, small network…). Maybe there is/are one(s), but I still haven’t found something consistent and have acted until now in guess/trial mode.

Beside this, and as a Windows user, I regularly stumble on an other issue, which is my main peeve with the present system : the SDA doesn’t show the same content, whether I am using my administrator account or my normal, day to day one, this, even if I run it with administrator rights. I encountered the problem again, very recently, when installing the full HALion 7.5.10 update. Something has to be done about this kind of issue. What is to be believed, the downloaded/installed states of my products shown under my administrator account or my usual one ? I rely exclusively on the former, but as a result, am unable to use reliably the SDA when working with my usual account. Each time I need to look in it, I have to close everything and change the Windows account used…

Additionally, I think that there should be, in these Steinberg forums, one dedicated to the eventual download / installation / licances issues. This would avoid the others to be sprinkled with countless licences related threads.

Keep on the good work ! :slightly_smiling_face:

Yeah, and with an authoriser for project related cloud functionality.

Thanks for the explanation. I’m just reporting a bad customer experience, comparing with all the other software I use. It’s not my job to design a better system, but it seems to me that some of the following would be fairly easy to fix, but Steinberg/Yamaha has decided to offload the pain to the user?

  1. round-trip to the browser to authenticate often doesn’t trigger correctly.

  2. a separate download code and activation code to be entered in different places is confusing

  3. Product naming and licensing is confusing. I have something Halion with Dorico, something Halion with Cubase, full Groove Agent, smaller Groove Agent, something Halion in the installer. I try to use it, app says not activated, I go to activation manager, sign in, is it not activated, or have I installed the wrong thing. Website tries to sell me something. Re-install. VSTSound updates go in a system folder. Disk is full. Move to external drive. Library manager can’t move. etc etc. This wastes time I wanted to spend working.

  4. A bunch of bundled instruments I don’t want. But it’s hard to separate out all the content from what I do want to use.

You must get a lot of support requests about this. (Although my support requests in Canada seem to eventually go to one person’s email inbox, and the answer months later is “it is what it is”, so I stopped requesting.)

Please take a look at Logic Pro or Ableton for clues about how to manage authentication, licensing, activation, and content. It’s not perfect, but it’s better.

re. Updates, yes I feel for paid upgrades to give us new effects and instruments while the core content-management functionality is such a mess is the wrong priority.

No system is perfect, but I think users, and Steinberg can do better with the only problem being available funds.

I totally agree