I haven’t posted here in the forums for quite a while, but there is a bunch of issues I’ve asked about in the past that still have no good answer. Risking sounding repetitive, how difficult is it to solve these issues that concern both the way lyrics look and the way you can work with them? I’ve been looking at update after update for quite some time now, watching really good features being added to Dorico together with features with a discussible narrow use, and watching many problems being solved. Still, most lyrics issues keep being overlooked, or their solution keeps being postponed. Several of the issues I mention below are not rare: they keep showing up all the time when I work in Dorico, and I believe they show up as well to almost everyone that works often with vocal and choral music. And yes, I have noticed some solutions to lyrics issues, like them remaining in italic after being changed, but many are still unaddressed.
Here are some of the issues I would love to see solved, numbered for reference in eventual comments:
-
Syllables in Galley View sometimes overlap horizontally when there is a system change in Page View, making them difficult to select for copying or erasing.
-
Lyrics in Galley View often overlap vertically with pretty much everything; this happens often when there are multiple lines of lyrics, but even lyrics in a single line can overlap with notes in lower ledge lines and spaces (very common in the altos). This issue has exactly the same problem as the previous one: it makes it difficult and sometimes impossible to select lyrics to copy or to erase.
-
Lyrics in Page View sometimes still overlap with other items, in particular with dynamics indications which are slightly unaligned vertically — is this issue related to the one of vertically overlapping systems?
-
Hyphens separating syllables in words that go across different systems sometimes overlap with the syllables themselves (it looks like that happens when the syllable goes beyond the vertical limits of the system).
-
Dealing with hyphens in first/second endings of repeat sections is quite time-consuming and requires some easily forgettable knowledge of fonts (I keep having to waste precious time looking for the solution). Much on this issue has been written in the forums.
-
Marquee selecting lyrics often does not work because the start of the marquee rectangle (where you click) is too close to a bar or some item and that bar/item is immediately selected, preventing the marquee rectangle from appearing (I wonder if it isn’t possible to program the marquee to always work as long as you keep pressing the mouse button, selecting an item only if you unpress the button?)
-
Marquee selecting lyrics often select just some of the syllables inside the marquee rectangle, even though many other syllables are clearly inside it. This causes the action of selecting lyrics to be needlessly performed more than once, and often several times.
These are the issues that come to my head: there might be others I don’t remember right now. I know that some of the issues are not that simple to solve, in that the changes would probably add to the computing time, or that they depend on things outside Dorico (like fonts). Still, there are plenty of Dorico features that make Dorico heavier and are not used by many, and there are ways Dorico can work around problems. I also know that some of the issues I mention have manual work-arounds, but these are often time-consuming and sometimes even unfeasible. As an example, increasing the vertical space between staves in Galley View helps prevent vertical overlaps, but that solution becomes much less handy if you have many staves in a system and you start needing to scroll up and down often. I’m not asking here how I can solve these issues myself manually: I’m asking the powers that be that such solutions won’t be needed any longer.
All in all, I do think Dorico could and should be better in the notation aspect of music writing, and that both working with lyrics and the way lyrics look in the score are two very important parts of that aspect. After some years of being a content user I am still waiting for Dorico to be the amazing music notation software I was promised it would be. It might be so for some users, but I doubt those work often with vocal and choral music.