Hi all,
I want to route my Main Output permanently to Virtual Audio Out 1+2 for main recording in VST Live.
The Problem:
Every time I save the project, close VST Live, and reload the project, the Main Output automatically resets itself and assigns to the physical outputs 7+8 of my audio interface. VST Live completely ignores my saved selection of Virtual Audio 1+2 upon startup.
That is true. It is quite unlikely that one wants to route the main channel to a virtual output. When you start VST Live on a different system, or you are just a novice, it will try to find a physical output no matter what, in order to prevent the user from hearing nothing at all. If you need to output to a virtual port, just create an output channel and route it to Virtual 7/8, and then route your channels’ outputs there.
Bass, Guitars, Vocal and Drums are directly connected with their 2nd outputs to the sound mixer and I use the inputs to the soundcard for the InEar monitoring.
During live sessions, I would like to record the guitar, bass, and vocal signals using the “Record Main Output to Local Folder” function, preferably as separate audio files. In this setup, the Main channel would be used only for recording purposes.
So create tracks and record there, no? We do that all the time, so you can rehearse if one or more musicians are not available, or for rehearsing alone, or just to check what was played before. Ciro records all shows live I guess, maybe he has some more advice
Yes the option with the single tracks and the record button and actions “start next song and record” will work, but I don´t like that the files are stored in the audio folder and I need to clean up the recorded tracks after every gig. The “record main channel” option I like much more as no impact to the current project and files are stored in a sperate recording folder.
@ciro1983811
Hi Ciro, may you have some advice for me?
Hi, @musicullum dunno if it is still as it was before, but internally recorded tracks once upon a time where stored in a subfolder audio/gigs … now it is gone … that was a good idea to differentiate imported audio (stored in audio/ ) vs recorded audio (stored in audio/gigs )
anyway yes I record everything in separate tracks per each instrument per each song! (to later analyze, remix, fiddle around etc). And yes I later keep what I want, Downmix all in a master if needed, otherwise I delete the tracks in the project and later clear all unused files exporting as archive and substituting the main project all togheter to erase unused audio files.
It would be great if the mixer offered an option to choose which outputs are recorded as separate audio files. Files are stored in recordings folder and no clean up would be needed.
Files recorded in the project belong to the project media type folder “audio” just like “midi”, “dmx”, “lyrics” etc. We don’t want to change that.
Recording main output is a special function and its result is not included in the project.
Sacrificing the Solo button in the channel view as you suggest would cause a sh…storm for good reasons But we’ll check if we can find a way to visualize record state.
In my case, I don’t use a main output, only separate output buses for bass, guitars, vocals and drums. Having a function like “Record Main” that records all output buses simultaneously to separate audio files, including their processing, would be extremely useful. This would greatly simplify my workflow, especially when recording rehearsals.
Of course, I don’t want to cause any trouble, but I think that in most live environments the main output is not used, as the sound mixer want to receive separate outputs for each instrument and vocal.
For me, the ideal solution would be a function such as “Record Main”, where selected outputs could be recorded into separate audio files.
As a short-term workaround, would it be possible to implement an option that forces the main output to a virtual audio device also after reloading?
If there is an FoH mixer human, then yes. But with VST Live you may run the show all from within, then MAIN is PA out. Which may also apply to rehearsal etc. And again, if you are a new user you’ll not start to use VST Live for the first time when the curtain falls
You can send your outputs to audio tracks using a virtual connection instead, then you can record whichever outputs you want to record.
In my case, I use the same setup during rehearsals as I do on stage, including separate outputs for my in-ear monitoring. However, I fully agree that using the Main Out for recording makes perfect sense for some users, just not for everyone.
I know how to record individual tracks, but the main advantage of the “Record Main” function is that the recordings are stored in a separate folder and eliminates the need for any cleanup afterward.
In my case, we use output buses both for rehearsals and live performances. Recording the outputs directly would provide a much simpler and more straightforward workflow than setting up audio tracks. The recordings could be saved in a separate folder, keeping the project clean.
Also, when working with a setlist of multiple songs, there would be no need to configure complex routing for each song. For example, if we suddenly decide to record an entire setlist, we could simply enable recording on each physical output bus, click Play, and perform the whole concert uninterrupted, all with just a few clicks.
This would also give us separate audio files for each output bus, ready to be imported into a DAW for further mixing.
The Main recording function records all the time, regardless of whether transport is started or not. The idea is to capture sparks of ideas, or “timeless” recordings. Your application appears to vary?
Exactly! I’d like to have the same always-on recording option available for all output buses, regardless of whether transport has started. This would make it very easy to record an entire live concert, with each physical output bus captured separately, including the breaks and audience interactions between songs. These recordings could then be used for mixing and even synced with the video footage to produce a live video.
I can’t, of course, speak for the devs here. But VST Live rather focuses on live performance than live recording. As much as both aspects share some solid common ground, it would, IMHO, be unwise to shift that focus.
I completely understand that VST Live is primarily focused on live performance, and I’m not suggesting changing that focus. This is simply a feature request.
Since VST Live already has the “Record Main” function, and offers much more complex routing options for recording to audio tracks, I thought extending the existing recording functionality to all output buses could be a useful addition.
Of course, only if it’s technically feasible and doesn’t compromise live performance in any way. I just wanted to share the idea, as it could provide a simple and practical way to record entire live shows with separate outputs.