Multi channel confusion

Hi,

basically I have the same problem as described in this post:

(“No audio at all when playing multichannel files with stereo output configuration” [the forum included a beautiful link to this forum thread, but doesn’t allow posting it :(] )

which was posted for WL11. I can patch a similar solution (“Channel configuration Filter: All Speaker Connections” instead of “Channel configuration: Universal”) but it does not work. I still get no audio output.

In a bit more detail: when I insert Steinberg Ambisonics decoder, I get asked about output configuration of the plugin, where I can select stereo, which makes the master go from 4 channels to 2 channels and I hear audio. When instead I insert a third party decoder (IEM binaural decoder) the channel count is still 4 channels, with no audio coming out of channels 3 and 4. (working with 1st order, 4 channel B-format Ambisonics here) This audio I cannot hear, even though I followed channel configuration suggested in the aforementioned thread.

Workaround 1: activate “mix to stereo” in master section. What is this actually doing? do I hear overlap between channels? right now I am listening on laptop testing out stuff in no critical listening environment. Gemini tells me there is a 6dB attenuation involved. Where does that happen? seems like a possible hack, when output should be a stereo file.

Workaround 2: define the channel configuration as “before Playback Processing”. This way I can have my 3rd party ambisonics decoder in my master effect chain and still hear the signal. This hack can also work in the same situation hack 1 would work, with the benefit that my levels are untouched.

HOWEVER: If I want to master an Ambisonics file into an ambisonics file, I want to have the possibility to A: select a stereo Output Bus with my IEM binaural decoder as effect on playback processing - that means the channel routing must happen AFTER the playback processing. then, B: for situations where I am on the go and do not have my headphone connected, I would prefer to choose a different Output bus, where Channel 1 plays to both L and R channels of the interface (since first channel usually is omni it makes as a good reference when quickly clicking through material) With no Ambisonics decoder in playback processing. or C: first and second channel into a mid side decoder, to see how well the Ambisonics master works with this easy decoding strategy.

Ideal scenario: Have the speaker arrangement method route channels of audio to audio interface channels and ignore if some channels are not possible to hear. Just play the ones that are patched.

Is this a bug? should this still work? How can I have control over channel count and patching inside the master chain?

Are you sure your audio connections are properly set in the preferences?

Even more confused now. You motivated me to double check everything (again)

This time it worked, kind of. Before I was doing the patching on a new bus, that I set to “Speaker Arrangement #2”. This still doesn’t work. When I patch “channel #1” and “channel #2” to my physical outputs on the Main Playback bus, I can hear the audio. I can then also hear it when I activate “speaker Arrangement #2”, even when I do not patch these channels in the that second bus. I thought I understood how this configuration was supposed to work. But since you ask: No I’m not so sure anymore.

I have no idea what these Left #1 Right #1 Left #2 Right #2 and so on (up to 32) are and I noticed that my idea of routing channel 1 of a multi channel file to both left and right speakers doesn’t seem possible.

Most importantly though: is it expected behavior that the patching of the Main Playback Bus should have any effect on what happens when I select speaker configuration 2?

I read pages 40ff in the manual, but, didn’t get more explanation there.

I am testing on a MacBook Air M4 using built in speakers for now

Please illustrate your case with various screenshots.

Hi again,

thank you for considering an explanations, I was busy out for work in needed some thought on how to explain this more clearly. So, the most pressing for the moment:

scenario A

main bus configuration:

and bus 2 configuration:

this results in no playback possibility for both speaker arrangements (1 and 2)

however:

scenario B:

when I add the patch of the second screenshot into the FIRST (Main Bus) configuration, so that both “Left/Right” AND “Channel #1/Channel #2” play to “Out 1/Out 2”, wave lab plays fine. If I then don’t patch anything on “Bus #2” Wavelab plays without error, but I don’t hear anything (as expected)

question:

Is this expected behavior? and if so, what logic applies? This is a very rudimentary multichannel example. I would like to understand this logic before building workflows for HOA and more complex sound cards.

Thank you for your consideration

WaveLab only uses one bus at a time. Hence, this is normal. The bus must be connected to all the audio output ports you need.

what I find confusing, is that I need to have the Main Bus patch “working”, in order for the second and third speaker configurations to work.

F.eks. I need to patch at least 2 Channels from the set of channels starting at 96 (screenshot #2) on the Main Bus. in order to suppress the warning about “Not all channels can be played back” warning.

Only doing this on Bus 2 does not suppress this warning. For my patching to work on Bus 2, It need to exist in Main Bus.

Then, if “Channel #1/ Channel #2” are routed to physical outputs on the MainBus I can start playback also with Speaker configuration 2 selected. In speaker configuration 2, I can omit any patching, not hearing anything, but wave lab still plays. Or I can only patch “Left/Right”, there I get sound.

I have not yet generated debugging files to find out what audio I am getting there.

assumption

various output patches can be defined as busses and assigned a “Speaker configuration” Button via the “Bus Category” Dropdown menu. the Bus “Main Playback Bus” is always assigned Speaker Configuration 1.

confusion

somehow the patching of “Main Playback Bus” changes how Speaker Configuration 2 works.

question

how do these two interact? I cannot find documentation for it.

took me a while to understand your reply. So you are saying WaveLab should only be using one bus at a time. I conclude that this means Bus 2 (assigned to “Speaker Configuration 2”) should not be influenced by the patching in Main Playback Bus. Thus the behavior I am explaining is a bug.

Where can we post bug-reports, so that this can be fixed in a future release?

The principle of the speaker configuration #2 to #7 is to send the same audio to different audio ports, to address different physical speakers. If you want to play 4 channels on the main bus and 4 channels on the the configuration #2, this one must also have 4 channels defined.
With this config, if you only play stereo (fewer channels), it will work also.

oh, so the intended behavior is that in the Main Bus, which is hardwired to speaker configuration #1, a internal output channel needs to be activated by patching it to a physical output. Then the other busses, which can be assigned to Speaker Configuration buttons can be used to route channels, which are routed in the Main bus, to other channels. Channels not routed in the Main Bus are intentionally not possible to patch in other busses?

They can.
You can use device ports #1, #2, #3, #4 to the main bus and you can also use device ports #5, #6, #7, #8 to the Speaker Configuration #2.
By selection the config #1 or #2, you will play through ports #1, #2, #3, #4 or through ports #5, #6, #7, #8

So how can I edit the routing and count of channels between editor and these output channels that I can patch to physical outputs?

Exemple: when I use the Steinberg Ambisonics Decoder plugin, it changes the signal to stereo (only two Master faders) and plays through Left/Right Channels. When I use the IEM Binaural Decoder plugin the signal remains 4 channels, even though the plugin only has two outputs. Channels 3+4 are silent in this case, while the binaural signal plays through Channels #1+#2.

Is it possible to have the output of the IEM decoder also be treated as stereo, inside the master bus?
Or even more important, if I want to decode onto a bigger loudspeaker array, I would possibly need more channels than the source audio.

Sorry, I was unclear: with “Channels” I was referring to internal channels in Wavelab, that have names like “left” “Channel #1” etc. not device ports.

I now understand that I need to patch at least 4 of these channels in order to be able to play (green moving playhead) a 4 channel audio file. Otherwise I get “Incomplete Audio Device Connection” error message. (Funnily enough WaveLab does not care about which channels get patched to the audio device, as long as there are enough. So if you have a surround setup patched out, Wavelab will play fine with moving playhead, but no audio is audible)

What confused me was, that if a channel is not patched to any device output in the Main bus, the patching for that channel in another bus will not work. Any channel one tries to patch in a speaker configuration #2 - #7 must also be patched in speaker configuration #1.

So Speaker configuration #1 is in some sense always active, because it defines which channels are possible to patch. “Possible to patch” of course is bad wording, since it is possible to patch even when they are not patched in #1. But such a patch doesn’t have any effect.

I guess this is intentionally? then some visual feedback about this would make things less confusing for newcomers. If this is not intentionally (I don’t know why it should be) I would regard this as a bug and try to find out how to write a bug report.

You do realize that you are currently communicating with “Mr. WaveLab” himself, right?

There is no more direct interaction than what you have right here, right now :wink: .

So, I don’t think you need to write a “bug report”.

See my Audio Connections setup: this is how I play both a 4-channel ambisonics file or a stereo file, using a single bus on my system. And without having to change anything when I switch from one to the other. However, I do not use plugins. I don’t know what your plugins aren’t doing.
There is no known bug here.