How do you know this? Where are the threads? Where did these people say feel free to give all this away without mentioning where you got it from?
Even in this thread where some very kind people have posted templates, they will still very much appreciate folks being directed to their original post. Rather than someone just redistributing them all with no acknowledgment whatsoever.
There are those of us that spend time trying to help people and all that’s expected in return is a little credit where it’s due. For me, my “credit” Is to make people aware of the YT channel also to have some nice chat about it.
Certainly we don’t expect criticism and people saying that your YouTube is a mess when we’re giving away things for free.
About the MIDI files thing. That’s also been done for donkey’s years. It’s nothing new. All my templates have a notepad with various information in them.
However, I’ve seen my templates redistributed on some forums with the notepad removed.
There’s nothing to argue about here. People give things up for free. They have the right to expect a little mention in return. Even if that is just a “Thanks” on a forum. (Which goes a long way).
Another very important point is that when you know the source of this free stuff directly, it enables us to support it. So if someone gets my Atmos templates and has no idea where it comes from, they won’t have a clue what some of the items are for, unless they are able to ask about it directly.
The same goes for most of these kind of things. It’s all about context…
Right that’s enough from me on this one.
To those of you who have received these little freebies without moaning or arguing about it, a huge thanks from me, it’s much appreciated.

I should add though, that I do appreciate your points in this. I’m certainly not trying to make rules. I just believe that people who do things for free should be able to at least receive thanks for it. And be able to answer questions and support it. None of these can happen if their work is redistributed by someone anonymously.
