Please remove this thread.

[ShikiSuen]

@pianoleo

I apologise for missing your idea of making both shortcuts work, and reject your (IMO pedantic) idea of of using the Ctrl key rather than the Cmd key on Mac - it would go against absolutely every other Mac program I’ve ever used.

One quick addendum: Cmd-Y performs the Redo action in BOTH Sibelius AND Finale. It may be that (given other Steinberg programs used Cmd-Shift-Z) THIS is the reason the default in Dorico is Cmd-Y.

Just a thought…

Then this surely breaks the hotkey consistency among Steinberg products. Cubase for macOS uses CMD+SHIFT+Z in lieu of CMD+Y, and so does Wavelab for macOS.

Reference:

Cubase Shortcuts Keys

F3/F4 (Undo/Redo) not working

I will also file the bug report to MakeMusic and AVID to allow them make CMD+SHIFT+Z work on their apps for macOS. Note that MakeMusic usually won’t be in a talking mood listening to feature requests from general public (but from their certain little social circle which consists of notationists in North America… just like Freemasonry but less mysteric).

Oh: My idea has nothing like what you said “rather than…”. I just pointed out the illogical way of using CMD key for hotkeys.

P.S.: Information from Wikipedia is helpful once the content of an entry is proved academically correct / reliable. It is generally used for helping paper writers think on what shall they do next, with required additional proof of source reliability.

EOF.