Problems with Compatible Aggregated Time Signatures

Here is my score:

Take FiveMSXZ.dorico (2.0 MB)

I use a 3/4|2/4 aggregate signature, combined into 5/4.

I have managed to have something tht prints raight and playbacks right, but with proofreading errors, that I am trying to solve. I have problems at the end which occur when I need to have “partial” bars. The first problem occurs before the Coda, and I am combining 2 challenges her, so I shall focus on the problem at the last bar.

The current version of the score attemps to address the problem using the “comma” syntax to truncate a bar. I now know that this does not work, so I tried to get rid of the aggregate nature of the Time SIgnature. Trying to update the current last partial bar takes me no where, I decided to drop ths bar (Shift-B, -1, Enter). and try to start from scratch.

image

I start by untying the top notes. and dropping the partial bar.

Now I try to generate a new full bar, by selecting the last existing bar, and hitting shift-R, and then Shift M, 5/4, Enter.

This seems to generate a non-aggregate bar (no dashed barline); but if I hide this signature and provoke signposts:

it can be seen that the active signature in the bar is still aggregate: “5/4 (q,3+2)” like the previous one! How can a “5/4, 4q” signature be produced?

The formula for a 4-beat pickup is 5/4,4, not 5/4,4q.

But it’s not clear to me what you’re trying to achieve. Can you provide some kind of image of what your desired goal is?

Actually the score in the project as I attached it is “picture perfect” and even playback-perfect. But Proofreading complains:
Barline is shorter that implied by Time SIgnature(-2 quarters) [Flow 1 Bar 106]
And I am trying to get rid of it.
I found a better way in a post by @christian_r

I made three little videos to explain different cases for editing the pick-ups. I hope can be of some help. Case A: you have written the full bar with rests -activate insert mode (global adjustment of current bar) -select the rests -press delete [pickup a]…
This works if I use Remove Rests rather than Delete. When I hide the new Time Signature, I still have:
Barline also includes a hidden Time Signature [Flow 1 Bar 106]
but the project already had that, so this is a major progress :slight_smile: !

Remember that proofreading messages are indicators of things that *might *be wrong, not things that are definitely errors. In a case like this, where the score looks and plays back the way you want it, I would just ignore those messages.

I know, I have ignored some red proof readings in my time :slight_smile: ! But when the rationale is not totally clear, it is worth it dive a little into it, you may learn something. In one another case, I discovered that I had some ghost data from an obsolete and unnecessary extra staff. It did no harm to picture nor playback, but i was worth finding out how to discover it and how to revea it, and to get rid of it. This time I learned something about Aggregate/combinable Time Signatures. I found the work-around. It was also worth it. Now I cold even get rid of the very last proffreading remaining here, but I won’t bother.
And some other time, once I have understood the proofreading, I disagree, and I ignore it :slightly_smiling_face: .

Thank you.