Repeats in the style of The Sacred Harp (1991/2025 revisions)

First post after a year of lurking following my conversion from Finale (which had me in its grip for 30+ years) .

Background: I occasionally set music in shaped notes, usually in the Walker 4-shape system found in The Sacred Harp. These are typically songs from other books that have their own idiosyncratic shapes (e.g., the shapes used by M.L. Swan in the 19th-Century New Harp of Columbia).

When I do this, I try to follow the conventions of the most common version of The Sacred Harp, i.e., the Denson book most recently revised just this year (and before that in 1991). Dorico makes shape notes much easier than Finale ever did, but I’m struggling with the repeat.

Dorico provides the option to use a four-dot repeat, as The Sacred Harp uses, but I can’t figure out how to follow the dots with two thick lines, as used in that book, e.g.:

A black and white image of a music note  AI-generated content may be incorrect.

I can get the four repeat dots followed either by a thin line/thick line combination or by a single thick line (by setting “Gap between thin and thick barlines for final barline” to 0 in Engraving Options), but I can’t figure out how to get the repeat dots followed by two thick bar lines.

Can Dorico do this, preferably without too much of a hack?

It’s not too bad, but this is all I can come up with:

In addition to setting that gap to zero, add an extra bar (or even just a quarter rest beat by typing Shift-B, 1q), set the final barline to “thick,” remove the rest, and use the note spacing tool to squish the bar down. I don’t love it, but it works.

5 Likes

Thanks, Dan. I thought the solution might be something like that, but I hadn’t found the it yet.

More generally: I’m deeply grateful for all of your contributions on this forum and various other sites. My (amateur) interest here is in shape note and other hymnody, and your writings have been invaluable. (And I have now volunteered to help a local church with the engraving for their in-house hymnbook, so you may see more questions from me.) Thanks.

2 Likes

That’s great! Happy to help.

1 Like