Hey, your song sounds like mine!
Here is a link to the sound: SoundCloud - Hear the world’s sounds
It is the last note that caught my attention as wavering noticeably flat.
Just to clarify, it caught my attention aurally first (around the time of the OP), and only then did I look at the actual sonics of it with tuners, etc., as per yesterday’s post. Understanding that tuners and displays like in VariAudio and RevoicePro3 aren’t as important as what is actually heard …
Here is the VariAudio to the soundcloud sound in this post:
Can’t tell at this scale, but the entire note is flat, at no point does any segment reach a true G (first segment about 17 cents flat, 2nd one is so flat it is a true F# (…!), next is 22 cents flat … the closest it gets is the last 3 short segments, when it is almost completely faded out, and there it is 4 cents flat).
Method: HSSE S90 to group track recorded into audio track.
: VariAudio above from that audio track.
: That audio track then rendered/exported to 44.1/16 with UV22HR … then the resulting .wav file uploaded to Soundcloud.
I’m at the stage where I’ve listened to it enough times that my brain is starting to play tricks on me. The only objective fact I can be sure of is that it caught my ear as sounding flat when listening to the project, long before I tried to do any quantitative analysis.
Then when I created the VariAudio and RevoicePro3 displays, the variations from “on pitch” seemed to be consistent with what caught my ear in the first place. There is of course possible confirmation bias there …
Finally, like I said in an earlier post, I am always the last one to hear when things are out of tune (guitars, etc.) … so if it caught my attention, that would usually suggest it is significantly out of tune.
But thank you for listening, and for your thoughts!