Silly little comma

Here’s a little aggravation: all I want is to have a comma after the metronome marks, e.g., q=90, Jazz Waltz.


I tried Ms google’s solution, followed step by step:

To insert a comma after a tempo mark in Dorico, you can use the tempo popover (Shift-T) to input the tempo mark and then add a comma and any additional text you need.
Here’s a more detailed breakdown:

  • Access the Tempo Popover:
    In Write mode, press Shift-T or choose “Write > Create Tempo” to open the tempo popover.
  • Input the Tempo Mark:
    Enter the tempo mark you want (e.g., “Q=100” for quarter note equals 100) directly into the popover.
  • Add a Comma and Text:
    After entering the tempo mark, add a comma and any additional text you want to include (e.g., “Q=100, andante”).
  • Confirm and Place:
    Click “Create” or press Enter to insert the tempo mark with the comma and text into your score.

I also read this:

To insert a comma after a metronome mark in Dorico, select the metronome mark, access the properties panel, and add the comma to the “Tempo (bpm)” value field, then save your changes.

Here’s a more detailed breakdown:

  • Select the Metronome Mark: In either Write or Engrave mode, click on the metronome mark you want to edit.
  • Access Properties Panel: The Properties panel should appear, showing the metronome mark’s settings.
  • Edit the Tempo (bpm) Value: In the “Tempo” group, find the “Tempo (bpm)” field and enter the desired value with a comma after it (e.g., “120,”).
  • Save Changes: Press Return or click outside the value field to save your changes.

If you replace the zeros after the 90, they just revert to the 4 0s when you leave the Tempo (bpm) “90.0000” value field.

Both solutions seem simple enough, but neither of them works.
This ain’t really mission critical at this point, but I’ll have a lot of these little duets to typeset in the near future. That will mean I’ll have to export svgs, add the commas in Illustrator. Multiple sorrow.
Any suggestions?
Let me know,
Thanks, Bill
(here’s a sample file I’m using for practice)
comma.dorico (1.1 MB)

Hi, @wmbrink, for such personalised Tempo marking, I would use System text, with a combination of MusGlyphs font (for the quarter note and the equal sign) and for example (as I see that you changed your Default Text Font to Helvetica) Helvetica regular at 9pt (for the number) and Helvetica Light at 11 pt (for the comma and the text), or other desired fonts and sizes. (You may want to manually align the text horizontally with the time signature:)

Dorico file example:
customized tempo text.dorico (597.7 KB)
Result:

1 Like

I’m curious: Was Google directing you to an actual page in the manual or the forum? Or was this just it’s AI summary? The latter is known to hallucinate.

3 Likes

Neither of those two paragraphs is anywhere in the manual.

2 Likes

Unfortunately, this is pure AI hallucination: a decent chunk of the Earth’s precious water supplies used up, and a nonsense answer generated, I’m afraid.

Value fields in Dorico that set numbers (like a metronome mark value) only accept numbers. They won’t accept a comma.

The tempo text field would though - but here I’m referring to the text field in the Properties panel, which can be freer with input than the popover, because it doesn’t need to parse for metronome mark values etc like the popover does.

Here’s the manual entry that will help you - I’d recommend bookmarking the online Dorico 5 manual and searching it directly. We’re still having some issues of the latest versions not ranking as highly in online searches than they should, but the native search is now rather good.

5 Likes

Sounds like a good solution; I’m gonna give it a try.
Thanks, Bill

AI hallucination; my bad. I just wanna believe everything I see on the innerweb.
Bill

Thanks
Bill

Thanks Lillie;
I was duped by AI. Won’t happen again, and I do have the manual bookmarked. I was just lazy.
Bill

2 Likes