Swap voice content differs when using shortcut

[cobeer]

Hi,
when doing a “swap voice content” using the context menu gives a different result compared to using a shortcut. I guess this isn’t supposed to be this way. I’m using D4.1 on Mac.

[dspreadbury]

Is that a pitched instrument, or perhaps a percussion kit? Can you attach a snippet of your project that exhibits the problem, so we can try to reproduce it ourselves?

Four simple guidelines to help us help you

We are proud to say that the Dorico forum is friendly, supportive and constructive, and it’s our aim to keep it that way. Members of the Dorico development and support teams closely monitor the forum, and this is the place you can have a direct conversation with the people responsible for designing and building the application. The forum is also frequented by many expert users of the software, who generously give of their time to offer assistance to their fellow users. In order to keep the discu…

[cobeer]

Hey Daniel,

here’s the project file. I’ve trimmed it down to one bar.
If you select the first 3 notes and do a swap voice content you get either extra rests (keyboard shortcut) or it behaves like it should (right clicking and context menu).
Hope this helps!

best
Janco

swap voice content bug 4.1.dorico (489 KB)

[dspreadbury]

I’m afraid I’m unable to reproduce this problem: whether I use the menu item or a shortcut, I get the same results, which is absolutely what I would expect, of course. Is it possible that you are mistakenly invoking a different command somehow via the keyboard?

[cobeer]

Hi Daniel,

thanks for you answer. I tried some stuff and found the problem: I had two key commands appointed to shift-v, and it took the other one

best
Janco