Tenuto/Staccato spacing inconsistency

I have three notes in a row (same pitch) that all have a tenuto/staccato articulation. On the third note the tenuto and staccato has a larger gap then the previous two notes. Why is this happening? To the reader it gives the impression that the third note is note the same (like it is descending). I can’t find anything in the Engraving Options or Properties Panel to adjust this. I would like them to all appear the same.
Tenuto & Staccato spacing issue.dorico (589.4 KB)

There is a setting in Engraving Options > Articulations > Vertical Position > Advanced Options > Staccato > Do not allow inside staff , but in this case I would slightly enlarge the stem in Engrave Mode to force the staccato to move up.

Ah ha!!! Easy fix. Thank you so much!

For me, I have to extend the stem by about half a space to get the staccato dot up, which then looks really … off. In fact, each artic look higher than the last!

They all look different, even the two first ones, I think.

Jesper

Please don’t shoot the messenger :wink:

The engraving option produces the same position of the tenuto/staccato group.

From the “calligraphy” perspective the best looking way is to move up also the beam and align the articulations manually.

I agree with the first part of your message! :grin: Setting the staccato to be outside the staff gives the best result.

Of course, the default behaviour is for slur and artics to be notehead-side.

I contemplated putting the articulations on the note side, but I opted to copy what the original manuscript had. I think this was done to make the dynamic markings less crowed. I often move slurs on the beam side if it makes dynamics and hairpins too displaced. Normally I would put this on the notehead side. Always a comprise!