I have just started experimenting a bit with OBS which could be quite useful for example as a very simple scaling solution and for image adjustments. I work with different solutions all the time, sometimes we have LED walls, sometimes projection, always from different positions and with adjustments needed to compensate. The video parameter controls in VSTL was a welcome addition but since they are on track level it would be a whole lot of tweaking to use adjust a while show.
What I quickly learned with OBS though is that it gets the signal from the Video Director, but i often use more than one video track during shows for a bit of overlays and crossfading. I figured out the workaround to use a video view in the way I’ve done it so far but to capture that window in OBS rather.than having it full-screen as my output. Downside: I need to have the window maximized as OBS apparently very directly mirrors it, actual resolution and all. Also the mouse pointer becomes part of it for some extra hilarity if you make that mistake.
Something that would be very useful is some kind of master video output track, same as how you can set up global layers for midi for example. Same kind of controls as on regular video tracks as well. Then the ability to send THAT to OBS (or via the Video Direcor), this would make VSTL even more powerful.
Maybe the functionality already exists? I’m a few versions back (3.0.17) as I always do extensive stress testing of the rig before committing to use it for shows so maybe it has been added already. Didn’t see anything like that in the version history though.
If you send videocontent to OBS you probably used the videodirector and it’s separated and resizable video view too, but u’re looking for and additional something because VideoDirector can’t do basic composites, right?
You are aware of the media player module, are you? Modules/Media Player.
As for compositing, this is a tricky issue. Compositing happens on the GPU, and it dead ends at the screen. Grabbing the image back from the GPU for further processing (OBS) unfortunately is very heavy on CPU (memory) performance, it is on our list to check if it can be done nonetheless.
I did that, and of course noticed that it’s one video track at a time. The workaround is to have OBS grab a specific window as I described, but it comes with some issues.
@musicullum Thank you for clarifying how this works, I haven’t worked much with video and my way of thinking goes more in line with audio processing. A number of audio tracks, output to bus for summing, bus output to master. I assumed that video was handled the same way inside VSTL.
So from what I understand, fades and correction and so on on video tracks is handled internally. Blending the different outputs=external GPU processing? One (admittedly a bit clunkier) way could maybe be if VSTL could have a number of virtual ports that would show up in OBS and the “summing” could take place there.
The media player would only be a solution if you could use it as an output source for video tracks I guess. But a solution like that would be very neat.
Multiple tracks and/or other video sources, yes, those are composited on the GPU.
Sounds great, but no idea how to do that.
I don’t quite understand that. The Media player plays one video file like tracks do; tracks are bound to Songs, that’s why the additional “global” player was added.
It composes (possibly along with other video sources) into the output (view) that is set in the Module interface.
Anyway, we are currently looking into ways to grab the composited GPU image and pass it along to OBS (and then, it would also be available in the Video Director). No promise, but there may be ways to do it in a way that is not too hard on CPU performance.
I should have been more clear, I was referring to audio in general (Nuendo/Cubase user since forever in my case), not how it works in VSTL specifically.
imho that would be over the top for VST Live. It makes sense in Cubase/Nuendo, but Groups are “Aux Channels”, but not tracks, and “Tracks” was merely supposed to be a simple backing tracks player - now look what you’ve done
Let me to enter here for a thought.
A master fader (to make faderportDARK||FullUP) would be nice, but no rush, no pressure, can solve some other way, (alpha is still important to me)
Yeah I agree that it’s not something totally necessary in the tracks window, at least it’s not something I myself would have much use for. Even less so due to two other things I wish VSTL had: individual track heights and showing data (or at least event presence) on folder tracks.
The mixer section/outputs/layers setup was a bit confusing right in the beginning though, mainly due to my background. But I think I’ve gotten a hang of it over the years.
While working on composite frames accesibility, thinking about that. It could be possible (and also would provide a “Master” fader for fkalmus)
We take you use OBS for compositing, what else would be missing in VST Live to provide that task? A Video Channel could have offset and size like video tracks, what else?
I knew this Q will come
My only idea is a fader in VD-window although then the feature will be exclusive to VD-usages only. But anywhere it is, I will just control it via MIDICC, probably will never keep it opened
In my case it has more to do with getting a single video feed to put into OBS, and the prime reason (again, in my own case) would be to scale/stretch the image, as well as possibly adjusting contrast/brightness/levels and whatnot. We have used Resolume for this but anyone who works with that will know 1) how insanely expensive it is, and 2) how it’s insanely overkill for the very basic functionality I’m looking for. I’m using two laptops for video and backing tracks (one main and one for redundancy), both go to an Atem Mini Pro. To use Resolume, we’ve had to run it on a 3rd laptop, using the USB port on the Atem to fetch the signal. Not a huge problem on road tours, more so with fly shows.
If I were to make a wishlist for additional video functionality in VSTL (and trying to keep it pretty simple), which could even bypass going through OBS in my use case:
A video channel as discussed, with basic adjustment possibility (brightness, contrast, etc)
Being able to stretch the output image if necessary (it happens now and then that locals have no solution at hand)
Video channel output possible to use in the video director, which opens up for using the external camera feed in my case which I’m eager to try out