I’m talking about my vinyl collection. Old vinyl before the CD took over had high manufacturing standards. While they were thin, the pressing factories knew what they were doing, and usually they played from start to finish without any major pops or garbage noise from poor pressing.
When the vinyl came back to life in the early 2010’s or so, most pressing facilities had no clue what they were doing and they started pressing vinyl in a way that made them sound like crap in some cases, or fine on others, but about half of them probably had dust particles or something that landed on them before drying, so that translated into very loud pops when playing them back. The worst example I’ve seen of this is Michael Giacchino’s “Star Trek Into Darkness”, but back in 2016 I wanted to buy most of the Genesis collection in new vinyl, and I had to send back to Amazon each and every one of them, and this is all their records from 1971 to 1986, so that’s a lot of records. And there were a couple that I had to send back more than once.
Queen has probably some of the worst quality new vinyl of any band. Greatest Hits II sounds like crap, not because of loud pops. It simply has poor sound quality. Sure, I’m an audiophile, so I’m more picky than most people, certainly the ones that buy $40 vinyl at Barnes & Noble and play them in a Crowley suitcase player with a tracking force of 4 grams that grinds the record every time it’s played.
And Queen’s “Kind of Magic” there’s a large batch of the new pressing that probably come from a poorly made master lacquer that has a skip, on the song “A Kind of Magic”, second song side B. I ordered a replacement. Same exact skip in the same exact place. My brother in law is a huge Queen fan, but not so much a fan of vinyl. For some reason he had this album, factory sealed, original pressing from 1986 or 87. He gave it to me. Obviously much thinner, but it doesn’t have a single skip, or pop, or anything than the groove background noise, and not that audible either.
So the thing is, new vinyl sucks. I’m not one of those old guys that say “everything old is great, everything new sucks”. This is just experience with old and new vinyl. I have about 400 of them, probably 300 are old and bought used. So those should be the ones that sound the worst, but they’re not, except for a few that were used and abused. But I also paid like $3 for them, so I wasn’t expecting no noise.
But the thing that stands out, even in those $3 used records, is that none of the old vinyl has any excessive loud pops that are as loud or louder than the music. But the new vinyl, half of them have them. I always send them back to Amazon, except for the Michael Giacchino one, because I was too busy with work and didn’t have time to open it for about three weeks, then I forgot to do the exchange before the end of the return period.
So my question was basically, if Wavelab Pro has some nice tool to fix loud pops and clicks from vinyl once it’s captured as WAV file.