I presumed it was better not to confuse issues with two questions in the same post, so here’s my second question:
is there ANY way to adjust the open string note below a whole note natural harmonic so that it is not off-kilter?
But, if it’s supposed to be sounding as a whole note, shouldn’t the bracketed notehead be a whole note as well?
Still a valid request, BTW, it’s better if the noteheads vertically align.
no, it’s a touch harmonic, the open string is only there as a guide t show which string it’s on, rather than have to include the I, II, III, and IV every time. It gets too cluttered, particularly in a contrabass part where there can be whole passages built in natural touch harmonics.
if that whole note were tied to another note in the next bar, there would be no open string note beneath it. it only appears on the first note.
the open string note in parentheses is sized smaller than a normal note.
So with a half or quarter note, that little note is only very slightly off-centre. It’s considerably more visible with the whole note, which has a larger notehead than the other two.
by the way, this is also the way Dorico does it by default when those options are chosen (natural harmonic/diamond notehead/show open string).
The only way I see currently is to fake the open string (deactivating it in the properties) with a cue sized, suppressed and bracketed note in a second voice, with a different Voice Column and with corrected x offset , and adjusted brackets position(you can copy that note to different places where the whole notes require it):
fake open string.dorico (1.3 MB)
OK, that would work.
but DANG it’s a lot of fidgeting about for a work-around.
I was hoping there might be some option in the engraving options.
it’s a shame, since that open string note doesn’t need to be connected to a stem or anything. it really should be centered to the whole note’s notehead.
The extra note is probably aligned with th eimagined stem the whole note would have if it had one.
Logical, I suppose, but neither attractive nor supported by historical practice (AFAIK).
Following the correct observation by @Derrek, here another easier and reusable way:
create a new Notehead Set with only one new notehead (insert a new one with the + and remove the one that comes with the new set). Then in the Edit Notehead dialogue, delete the glyph of the black notehead and inset the noteheadDiamondWhole. Set the stem as shown in the picture, and delete all the other stems values. Save as default clicking on the star icons.
In your score, when you have a whole note with that harmonics, apply the newly created notehead set (select>right click>Noteheads).
(The only thing I could not influence is the position of the brackets. You can do it in the properties panel, activating the bracket, and reducing it to only one note, etc…but is probably not necessary)
Result:
Dorico file example: