Any ideas why Dorico is condensing the clarinets as upper/lower stems and oboes as ‘a2’ for the exact same music? Later the clarinets are getting a2 - which is what I would like to see.
Well, there must be something different between the two, even if you don’t see it… because that’s how it works (I actually use this as a proof-reading tool!)
Dorico considers a musical phrase as all the notes between rests, and in this excerpt, I see no rests… so it’s a kind of long musical phrase. Each musical phrase gets its own condensing settings but you can override this using a condensing change. I mean, this is the fast way to go if you just want to correct this without looking for the tiny difference between the two…
Are there any dynamics? a tiny change of length in a gradual dynamic is enough to cause such thing.
Great! thanks - something must’ve been different - I recopied clarinet 2 from 1 in this section and it’s now a2
I guess it was the (barely visible) forte in the 2nd clarinet, but we may never know
If both clarinets become forte at that point, both must show forte, best checked in Galley View.