One should get a sense of humor.
One can only find something humorous if one is familiar with the terms/tropes/memes, etc., and how they relate to the subject being discussed. In an effort to find out how “toe pick” might be relevant to Dorico and this thread, I took the advice which I often give to others and did an internet search. A toe pick appears to be used in ice skating, particularly for jumps, launches, spins and pivots in figure skating, and is generally unwanted in ice hockey.
I am still puzzled.
You can’t make any assumptions about a Dorico 7. It has not been announced or even hinted. And you cant expect your wishlist to suddenly be implemented in any case.
I don’t see what’s wrong with making a keyboard shortcut that you like to toggle on and off. Pretty simple, very convenient.
He’s referencing an obscure 90s movie called The Cutting Edge. Unless you skated or had kids that did, you probably didn’t see it. (My daughter skated 3-4 years in elementary school so I’m sure I have the DVD down in my basement somewhere.) Given the international composition of this forum, I’d be shocked if more than 0.1% here have seen it, but basically the hockey player keeps tripping over his toe pick when he first tries to figure skate.
I’m not sure the comparison really works because it’s so easy to program a key command for the Show/Hide Signposts toggle. I have mine set to the upper left key on my keyboard so I can easily hit it without looking. I never struggle with clicking behind a signpost as I’ll just toggle them off.
You’re right … Keyboard shortcuts are a viable solution. I have created many in Mac OS that clash and that I don’t wanna get rid of, nor do the (maligned by many) “Twister” finger dance (the 70’s/80’s game). I use my fingers to actually play music for a living as well and the tendonitis of the finger dance is driving me insane. ![]()
My feature request suggestion was/is to move the Signpost off the side as current sign postages of Staff Visibility, text, system text, chords, tempi and other such items that I can not mention off the top of my head is illogically and unreasonably bunched up in Dorico.
The default maddening “bunch behavior” of many aspects of Dorico (the Engraving bunch of staff spacing when one needs to show/hide staff spacing comes to mind and haunts my nightmares, daymares, and midafternoonmares, daydreammares) really needs fixing as no other Program/App acts in such a punitive way. All this considering that Dorico is clearly the best of any notation ever, but, the “bunch behavior” needs a revamp.
I just use the ~ key for the Show/Hide Signposts shortcut. There’s no “finger Twister” and on a US English keyboard it’s simple to hit with one hand without looking.

You can also have them off by default if they annoy you that much and just turn them on when you absolutely need them.
I honestly like the reliability of the signpost placement. If identical signposts were sometimes above beat 1 and sometimes in the margins, I think that would be annoying too. The ease of toggling on/off with a single key just makes the placement a non-issue for me, even when they are obscuring other elements.
The whole “Toe Pick” thing … c’mon … let’s not use sarcasm and humor and be serious on this thread, ok! ![]()
Yes, pressing the “`” is a great feature for flickering on and off (see my screen grab below) and to toggle, like a video game “fire” button, and needs to be held down, its not like a “light switch” (up for on, down for off), which would be the ideal use for it. Can it be set as an on/off button? If it were, then I’d toe pick away, I say!
Its like piano vs organ …
Pianist: Hold down Pedal/Play octave on first beat/5 finger chord above/all rings out nicely
Organist: Can set up their MIDI organ (not pipe organ … some can, most don’t) with some foot pedal trickery settings, but, basically can not play the above, …it’s played differently, ie., held down sustained notes, whereas piano while not sustain indefinitely.
However, in my use case, I have to work with many massive 10MB projects (for my publisher and studio) that have 500+ pages (in one project) and up to 50 flows (in one project) with Cantai that use a bunch of Silicon RAM, CPU & GPU and SSD usage, so I am running into issues of when I have used the “`” and its need to keep it held down (organ/Twister), then CMD+3 to go to Engrave to actually move the thing.
And, I am running into an issue with Dorico with these massive problems, even on my pretty decent Macs [ M1 Mac Studio (2TB/32GB), M4 MacMini (1TB/24GB) and M3 MBA (2TB/24GB) ], where Dorico (seems to be having issues because of the amount of flows that I need to have per project per my publisher) is not letting me (for instance) double click the “Tempo” or double click the “Text” to change or edit it; all (probably, not sure) exacerbated by how much CPU resources Cantai demands of my [once capable] Macs. Which for my use is causing Dorico not function properly and using “`” is not a great solution for me. Others have reported similar issues with Cantai and AceStudio and the like even in Sibelius, MuseScore. I prefer to stay in Dorico, which is why I am asking for help and advice here on the forums so …

… In all seriousness. I have been just toe picking the system track and turning off sign post and then turning them back on which is fine.
Again, in my use case having a massive project and having the need to have many flows (Choir and Organ only … Lead sheet only … Dsc1, Dsc2, Sop, Alto, Tenor, Bass, Organ … DAW Export Flow for Logic/Cubase with their own tempo markings), so, I know it’s weird for many of you that I need to have access to Staff Visibility via Sign Post when i need them at certain times but not others depending on the flow and that I don’t need to have Dsc1, Dsc2, Sop, Alto, Tenor, Bass, Organ on every single page, but just Sop and Organ for a few systems on just one page … I get it … I am the weird one. In my workflow, I can not do the “Compose now, engrave later”. I work in dailies where I need to give singers a usable score as I compose, or rearrange, or correct.
In any case, thanks for the response, and stay serious, will ya!
I think you may be misunderstanding @FredGUnn.
On Windows you can temporarily hide all non-printing elements by holding down the backslash key, and on Mac it’s the backtick (`) key. (These are on a US keyboard.) But I think he has mapped the tilde, which is above the backtick on a US keyboard, to the View > Hide Signposts key command, which turns off display of signposts. This command is actually a toggle so that the first press of the tilde hides the signposts (and you can then go about your business), and the next one shows them again.
Right, Hide Signposts is really misnamed as its function is actually Toggle Signpost Visibility. I guess I actually have ` as the shortcut and ~ is still Hide Invisibles, oops, but the point is I can easily hit it with my left hand without looking so I don’t have to move my right hand off my numpad or mouse.
In any case it’s simple to toggle the signpost visibility on or off.
Thank you ALL for taking time to reply, I really appreciate it and appreciate you’re taking time to send your solutions. You are all in the majority, and I am the one that has the niche need to (as this thread title says) “Dorico 7 Signpost Placement Change FEATURE REQUEST Sign Post” …
The Signpost Placement probably won’t change for one user, but a girl can dream … always a bridesmaid, never a bride. No I am not a female, nor am I making fun of females. I am making more of my jokes that 40% of you all find funny.
I don’t think anyone has complained about use of humour in general, but the big images are a bit much. I know that Internet culture varies widely in that regard. I have visited forums where people use things like that a lot, and even places where people have signatures with animated gifs in them. Some people think that makes a place more friendly, while people like me find it to be draining energy. In my opinion, that’s not appropriate for a professional forum like this one.
If you’re used to that culture, the lack of flashy stuff might seem strict and boring to you, but from my point of view images like that makes a place less friendly rather than more so.
In addition, the tone of jokes can be difficult to take across cultures. You say that it’s intended as humour, but to me those inserts in your posts come across as hostile and aggressive. You may have intended your jokey language and images to be friendly, but to me it reads the opposite.
I don’t mind humor or images in the forum at all but the movie being referenced …
-
was released 34 years ago, before some forum members were even born.
-
has nothing at all to do with any sort of relevant topics like music, music notation, software development, interface design, etc., that might mean that forum members have seen it.
-
did not have a theatrical release outside of US and Canada, and this is an international forum of a German company (and a subsidiary of a Japanese company) whose entire development team is based in the UK.
-
was not critically well-received. (53/100 on Metacritic, 59/100 on Rotten Tomatoes.)
It’s a pretty big leap to assume anyone would even get the reference to something so obscure. Without anyone, possibly other than myself, even getting the reference there’s no shared cultural experience to make the joke “work,” so most were just wondering what on earth was going on. Here’s the Rotten Tomatoes summary: “Part contrived romance, part hackneyed sports drama, The Cutting Edge shows how difficult it can be to figure skate through cheese.” If that sounds appealing to you, feel free to watch.
Alternatively, I’d like to remind everyone of this forum’s Ignore button. It’s serving me quite well.
C’mon guys, focusing on the humor is really distracting, let’s keep it on subject, please.
New movies that have been released in the past 5 years are much better, you’re right.
Being Dutch, which means: from a country where ice skating (not hockey, or ice dancing, but racing and touring) is a national madness as soon as temperatures drop below zero, I can reassure you I didn’t get the joke/reference at all. TBH, the images you posted (repeatedly) looked sarcastic and obnoxious to me. I understand, and accept (and welcome!) that you’re joking, but it didn’t work for us extraterrestrials out there.
No hard feelings, I wish you happy foruming anyway!
Lots of posts contain graphics, primarily images of notation or a screenshot that helps explain a problem to be addressed, or occasionally an amusing trope. That is different from gratuitous images on multiple posts that seem designed more to call attention to the poster than to illustrate a notation solution or make a rare (truly) amusing point.
aaaaaaaaaaaand back on topic.
today while working on a score, I had to have Signposts showing, and in a number of spots, there were so many Signposts that they stacked one above the other, and the very top Signposts were actually OFF the page itself, which actually made them difficult to access.
It would really be nice if Signposts did not cover up tempo markings, or text, or other things, and it would be VERY nice if they didn’t reach off the page where they’re difficult to get at.
I know that I can reduce the zoom level of my page which will free up a bit of space above my document, but doing so makes things SO tiny that they are difficult to read.
Someone once suggested being able to adjust the transparency of Signposts. I thought that had been implemented, but if it was, I was unable to find the controls. That would certainly be one way signposts could be made less intrusive for those who find them covering up important information.
Perhaps in a future version, the same “desktop” as in InDesign could be used to show anything that falls outside the paper anyway. The “W” option toggles between the true print and the full desktop.



