How do I prevent this ugly mass of ties when doing manually arpeggiated chords?

Here are two instances in my score. How do I remedy this? Or is it more societally acceptable than I think?

Welcome to the forum, @bac0ntoast!

Indeed, it’s not ideal. And using one voice per note would produce too many voices (i.e. would be also hardly legible).

I, for one, would rather notate that in one of this two ways:

(assuming it’s a piano, for the second example).

Hi @bac0ntoast, adding to the suggestion by @charles_piano, it depends on instrument and desired end result. Can you sketch your desired end result on paper and upload a picture of it?

Here some possible variations [Edit: added version 2b: thanks @charles_piano! ]:

Dorico file example:
different tied:long notes:chords visualisation.dorico (1.4 MB)

Also Ă  la Beethoven, I think :slight_smile:

You are right, @charles_piano :grinning_face:

(another variation, following the manuscript: thanks @charles_piano!):

Here we are, perfectly readable like this :grin:

I thought he was deaf, not blind. :wink:

Jesper

@charles_piano @jesele
You are all so awesome funny!!! :rofl:

I am laughing out loudly:!

(It’s very good after a hard day of classes… )

Also doable with only one voice (and tuplets) for the dowstems :slight_smile:

Ohhh, elegant!

Of course. :wink:

Jesper

The “ala Beethoven” version (2a) is the best of both worlds to me. Failing that, I would recommend your fourth solution or either of the solutions from @charles_piano (or the third later on—his take on version 2, also your version 2b). But if version 1 is too dense, I see version 3 as too spare.

Of course, it will be up to OP to decide in the end; you have plenty of options here!

Edited to reflect the addition of version 2b in the post I initially replied to, after @charles_piano . Note that 2b is newer, and 2a was just 2 initially.

Thanks for the help! I will use the pedal method as it is a piano indeed. The left method also looks quite elegant too.

Hah! This is what my scores and parts looked like once upon a time!

I imagine Beethoven looks at us all from wherever he is with a little envy.

hi @bac0ntoast, there is a much easier way to do this to achieve better results. simply write your 4 eighth notes and your half note, select all the eight notes, and press “Tie”. Alternatively, if the notes are in different voices, you can select each individual note and press tie, or select the from and destination notes and press tie.


If you select a note in any score and press tie, Dorico will try to find the next instance of that note in that voice and tie it, even if the tie extends across multiple measures. This only works if the notes are in the same voice.

If the notes are in different voices, you can still tie them. Just individually select the two notes and press tie.

For a long time, I wanted to produce these arpeggiated chords found in a lot of piano music. Dorico came out with an update a couple years ago that made this possible.

Here is a related post: Notating arpeggiated chords