So far, in another program, my workflow to quickly copy & past Chord Symbols was to select the passage (bars) with what I wanted to copy, then filter for Chord Symbols, and then copy & paste.
In Dorico, the Chord Symbols aren’t selected along with the notes when I click in an empty area of a bar. It would be nice to keep the existing workflow in that respect.
Dorico used to offer this functionality. The problem with it was that it was exceptionally easy to edit or delete all of your chord symbols while cutting and pasting, because if you pasted over existing chord symbols it would replace with whatever you were pasting.
In “the old software” if you made an editing mistake in, day, a guitar part, you’d see instantly because you’d be able to refer to the (original) chord symbols in the bass part. In Dorico they’re all linked. It was a recipe for disaster.
The team introduced the current behaviour as a temporary fix, but they’ve stipulated that they’re looking to implement something better.
On a related note: Now that I have to select Chord Symbols with a marquee, it would be nice to able to intersect with the marquee and still select. Other Software makes the selection behavior selectable…
This
right now selects nothing!
And it would be nice to have a basic align functionality in engrave mode!
The way I selected them insures that there’s nothing else selected, especially when space is tight. Illustrator selects like this, and in Affinity Designer you can actually choose your preferred way of selection. It’s just something I’m used to, I guess…
Yeah, but in Dorico it’s quicker to draw a whopping great marquee selection and then go Edit > Filter > Chord Symbols (which is quicker still if you’ve mapped it to a keyboard shortcut, which I have)
I am not getting it. I didn’t use Dorico when the chord symbols were automatically included in the selection, but the way it is now is a huge pain. I have a 32 bar section I want to duplicate and move to a new key. I can move the notes OK, but how do you go about including the chords in the selection on such a large section?
Likewise when I go to transpose, if I am not careful I will leave the chords out of the transposition, which seems as bad as any errors that might have happened under the prior scheme.
Zoom out and draw a big box with the mouse. Bear in mind that you can go into a part layout and do the selection and the pasting there, where 32 bars likely don’t take up much space. The chord symbols will still copy correctly to all instruments that are set to show them.
I’ve just run into something: I’m trying to manipulate multiple Chord Symbols in Engrave Mode, and they select fine with the Marquee, but the filtering doesn’t seem to work?